6 ms·
In theory, that's why we have the notion of "probable cause" and warrants, etc. But what we have instead, is a "rubber stamp" mechanism from a secret court whi
by mindcrime 13y ago
In theory, that's why we have the notion of "probable cause" and warrants, etc. But what we have instead, is a "rubber stamp" mechanism from a secret court which - essentially - is completely free from an accountability to the American people.
Given that, I don't really care so much what the NSA tries to do... I now realize that the real answer is promotion, advocacy and education around technological tools to evade their snooping (assuming, for the sake of argument, that they can't break strong crypto). My goal going forward is to dive into helping promote the use of, and education regarding, Tor, I2P, PGP, and their ilk. Part of that is going to mean educating myself to a considerable degree as well, as I've admittedly been too cavalier about this stuff in the past.
- tptacek 13y agoAll federal courts are (basically) free from public accountability. That is literally one of the objectives of the design of the Judicial Branch; complain to the founding fathers.
- mindcrime 13y agoIt's not quite the same thing though. Yes, judges are appointed for life, and can't (usually) be removed from office, etc. But with the "regular" federal court system, at least we know who the judges are, who appointed them, and we can see / read / review the actual decisions and what-not. To me, that's a pretty marked difference from the FISA courts. Nonetheless, I do agree with your basic point. When I get my hands on a TARDIS, I'll be sure to let Thomas Jefferson know how I feel about all this! :-)
- tptacek 13y agoFISA judges are US District Court judges. We don't know exactly which ones they are (for no good reason, I agree) but they aren't, as I understand it, random party functionaries. (Crazy that anyone would have modded you down; did my part to try to fix).
- adestefan 13y agoWe do know who appointed them. They are 11 federal judges who are appointed to 7 year terms by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. At least 3 must live within 20 miles of Washington, DC, they can only serve one term, and none can be sitting on the Court of Review.
- mindcrime 13y agoI stand corrected. But the more important point is that the decisions and discussion are private and without oversight, and the presumption that they basically "rubber stamp" all these surveillance requests. Now, maybe they don't just "rubber stamp" everything. But without more info, who's to say? Edit: Also, for anyone more interested in details of the FISC (some of which I obviously misremembered), here's a good resource: http://epic.org/privacy/terrorism/fisa/fisc.html http://epic.org/privacy/terrorism/fisa/fisc.html
- tptacek 13y agoThe rubber stamp argument is brandished in any discussion about FISA anywhere, from message boards to NPR. But it's not hard to see that there are at least two phenomenon that can account for it: (1) That FISA courts are not a meaningful check on the authority of NSA and the FBI to surveil people, or (2) That the overwhelming majority of FISA cases involve prima facie legitimate surveillance targets. I do not find (2) that hard to believe. I'm not a firm believer in FedGov competence, but I really don't think NSA analysts are making up random targets; neither, for that matter, does Snowden, who intimated as much when he was interviewed. (Just because I don't think surveillance in the 2000's has been abusive, it does not follow that I think we should be unconcerned with checks on surveillance).
- dragonwriter 13y ago#1 is true whether or not #2 is true, because there is no adversarial process in the FISA courts. A one-sided legal process is never a meaningful check. With regular courts, even when the initial process is similarly one-sided (as it is with search and arrest warrants), the fact that the outcome will be subject to adversarial process down the road is something of a constraint (but, even then, I don't think anyone is going to be point to the regular warrant process as a particularly strong check on executive power.) The FISA warrant process, because of its secrecy and because it is generally not subject to downstream adversarial process, isn't a meaningful check. If the judges on the FISA Court are extremely diligent, it might be better than nothing, but given the secrecy around it, its unlikely that anyone not directly involved will ever really know whether or not it is (which is one of the things that makes it less likely that it will be.)
- baddox 13y agoI disagree. I think the incentives of all branches of government are very similar, and I do think this is a flaw in the design of the United States government. However, I don't think the founding fathers could have done any better, because I believe this is an inherent flaw with any government.
- tptacek 13y agoThe people don't vote for federal judges, who have lifetime tenure. Federal judges are thus insulated both from popular opinion and, to some extent, from politics. That's all I meant.
- baddox 13y agoI find it hard to believe that you actually believe federal judges to be in any way insulated from politics. Being subject to elections is in no way the only incentive affecting those in political power. People like to be well-known and well-loved, they like to be on the news, they like to have other people in power "on their side," etc.
- tptacek 13y agoI chose the words in my comment somewhat carefully. I don't know how much clearer I can make the comment I wrote upthread for you.