2 ms·
It is not incorrect. Heck, it's even been tested on the bar exam as part of the MBE, using the canadian fishing example I gave, which is a real MBE question bas
by DannyBee 13y ago
It is not incorrect.
Heck, it's even been tested on the bar exam as part of the MBE, using the canadian fishing example I gave, which is a real MBE question based on a real case (I am a bit too lazy to look it up).
This is how the case has been interpreted by every court to follow it. See US v. Guitterez, 983 F.Supp. 905 for a fourth amendment example from the 9th circuit.
Here is another from the fifth circuit:
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. ARMANDO PORTILLO-MUNOZ (i don't have cite handy)
"Portillo relies on Verdugo-Urquidez and argues that he has sufficient connections with the United States to be included in this definition of "the people," but neither this court nor the Supreme Court has held that the Fourth Amendment extends to a native and citizen of another nation who entered and remained in the United States illegally"
There are something like 2000+ cites to Verdugo, and and the general viewpoint of courts so far is as i said it is.
If you've got a court of appeals or SCOTUS cite to the contrary, where a court has held that they do apply, i'd love to see it.
- kevinskii 13y agoThanks, I stand corrected. For anyone else interested, The Volokh Conspiracy blog has a detailed post on this very topic: http://www.volokh.com/2011/06/13/the-constitutional-rights-of-illegal-aliens-under-the-first-second-and-fourth-amendments/ http://www.volokh.com/2011/06/13/the-constitutional-rights-o...