3 ms·
> Spending and making laws are all about the consent of the governed. Laws should be about the informed consent of the governed. Security built on a lie is sti
by belorn 13y ago
> Spending and making laws are all about the consent of the governed.
Laws should be about the informed consent of the governed. Security built on a lie is still a lie even if people feel more safe. During the first days of 9-11, the military sent personal down to the airport to reinforce peoples perception of safe travel. What they did not tell anyone at the time, was that the guns did not have any ammunition in them. Instead, the military were basically posing as an "armed force", because having guns with ammunition at airport would then actually create a security issue at the airports.
The security theater of the US feels somewhat like a doctor who has started to only give out placebos to his patients. If anyone feels better, sing praises, and if anyone get worse, give them more sugar pills. Soon, everyone start to get sick on the sugar alone, while the sugar pill manufacturer crave for more sick people.
The security theater from 9-11 has gone on long enough. People are not going to feel more safe from it, and will just get sicker on the solution.
- finnw 13y ago> Laws should be about the informed* consent of the governed* That is a huge can of worms, because it depends on being able to determine who is and isn't "informed."
- nasmorn 13y agoIt sure doesnt help if the government constantly exagerates the severity of the issue. This naturally leads to disinformed consent. Not lying so much and not keeping so many secrets would go a long way. Just a decade ago Clinton faced impeachement for trying to keep an affair secret and then lying about it. Nowadays Obama can just do a "no comment" about how many vitizens he is secretly asassinating.
- belorn 13y agoInformed meaning not lied to, not tricked, not mislead. If the government need to use the tricks of criminals to create new laws, then the government is doing something wrong.
- clarkmoody 13y agoOne of the primary protections against the will of the masses regarding policy was the election of senators by the state legislatures. The Founders saw the value in a House of Lords / upper chamber that was not _directly_ beholden to the whims of the people, but rather to the states themselves. That's been gone a long time now, and what we've got are more-powerful, longer-termed representatives sitting in the Senate. I don't claim that abolishing the 17th will fix much now, but it probably would have helped significantly over the last 100 years.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>Security built on a lie is still a lie even if people feel more safe. Not only that, even if you concede that making people feel safe (as distinct from actually improving their safety) is a legitimate goal, the existing system is an outrageously poor way of satisfying even that. If the goal is to increase the perception of safety then we could certainly do so without spending trillions of dollars, destroying privacy or enabling dangerous levels of government power. Just bring out the dog and pony show. Tell everyone that there is at least one secret sky marshal on every plane who is trained to assassinate anyone who tries to hijack it and run a bunch of ads about how badass they all are. Permanently station a canine unit at every major airport and let everyone see the cops with the dogs continuously sniffing around everywhere. There are innumerable things like that which don't cost trillions of dollars or bring about any serious cause for objection which allow the public to see that something is being done to address their fears. Compare this to the NSA surveillance apparatus, which is no doubt costing many billions of dollars in and of itself, creates an enormous high value target for hackers and foreign spies, and couldn't have possibly made anyone feel safer if it had continued to be held a secret as intended because the general public wouldn't have even known it existed.