4 ms·
Why does software have to be maintained?
- mpyne 13y agoOf course, sometimes the dock really is moving too. Like when you try to recompile your tried-and-true system with a new compiler and discover you'd really been utilizing undefined behavior...
- mitchty 13y agoOr the cases where you find out the dock was bad all along. I'm thinking of the cases where things "work", but aren't correct. Security bugs like a 32bit value getting used for privilege escalation. Or off by one errors. There are numerous ways in which you have to maintain software.
- jng 13y agoIf you are trying to compile the software with a new compiler, then you are changing the environment. And then it's expected that you may need to change things. Software has the most complex interfaces between parts, and it's nearly impossible to even verify that you haven't changed an essential part of of the contract. Of course this also hints at how we may build more reliable and resilient software in the future...
- jng 13y agoI love this kind of thinking. We are often missing a real clear understanding of even major things in software. Questions like "Why does software development take so much time", "Why can only developers write software', and this "Why does software have to be maintained" are in dire need of deeper analysis and understanding. In the long run, real evolution in software development will come from understanding these questions.
- jimmaswell 13y agoWhy can only developers write software? What kind of tautological question is that? If you write software you're a developer, even if not necessarily a good one.
- jng 13y agoMost people can tally up a sum. Most people can write a letter or note. Most people can sing a song, even if probably out of tune.Most people can draw a map or simple diagram. Nearly all people can communicate by talking. On the other hand, most people can not write even a tiny piece of software. I think that will change in the future. But there's a lot to be done until we are there.
- kawera 13y agoDan Bricklin wrote a very nice article on the subject: http://changethis.com/manifesto/show/6.200YearSoftware http://changethis.com/manifesto/show/6.200YearSoftware
- ChuckMcM 13y agoInterestingly, some network software seems to have nearly frozen. There are people out there running really really old, but still functional pieces of software (like thttpd) that doesn't really need maintenance, especially if the OS doesn't change.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoHmph, interesting points are raised, I suppose we shouldn't call it software maintenance when fixing a bug but, software upgrades! ;)
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoGood question. Why revisit the software that runs things like the segway, the space station, the pace maker, the artificial kidney, and a DVR? Maybe if you want to build a new one, maybe for "security", or maybe you just want to write some code. I like old software much better than updated software, because the latter is pretend and really unknown.