4 ms·
It's being attacked because the surrounding countries fundamentally object to the existence of an Jewish state and wish to destroy it. To say "Israel has apart
by gadders 13y ago
It's being attacked because the surrounding countries fundamentally object to the existence of an Jewish state and wish to destroy it.
To say "Israel has apartheid" really cheapens the struggle of Black South Africans.
//edit//Corrected glaring typo.
- carlob 13y agoYou probably wanted to say 'Jewish state'. Anyway I don't think I disagree with you: the surrounding countries do not want a Jewish state on their land, it was more or less imposed on them after WW2 and it has kept expanding ever since. Can you blame them for not wanting them?
- gadders 13y agoJews have lived in that region for thousands of years. It's not like there were none there and they all were bussed in.
- rangibaby 13y agoActually, they "all were bussed in". > By 1948, the population had risen to 1,900,000, of whom 68% were Arabs, and 32% were Jews (UNSCOP report, including bedouin). > According to Israel's Central Bureau of Statistics, as of May 2006, of Israel's 7 million people, 77% were Jews, 18.5% Arabs, and 4.3% "others". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Palestine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Palestine
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoYour second figure doesn’t include Gaza and Judea & Samaria, while your first figure does. If you would include those areas, the percentage of Arabs in the area would be over 50%. Most people in historic Palestine, be they Jews or Arabs, can’t say their family lived there 100 hundred years a go, the population has grown twenty-fold in the last century. However, there have been Jews and Arabs in that region for thousands of years. It would be silly to deny that.
- rangibaby 13y agoOf course, on your second point. I think one way to peace would be for Israel to simply annex the occupied territories. It's preferable to the BS situation that exists now. Both Israelis and Palestinians have a right to (literally) the same land. I would like to see Israel extend it's democracy and rights to the Palestinians instead of putting them in open air jail (the West Bank wall reminds me of Escape from New York).
- devcpp 13y agoRight. Israel has "kept expanding". Ignore the strategic positions that allowed them to survive (the Golan), ignore the repeated aggressions from the Sinai which made Israel have to take it and give it back several times. Besides, are you saying that wanting someone out of some place but justifies violence? If so, expect me to come at your house and get you out of there with a rifle and don't complain when I do so.
- thwest 13y ago>> To say "Israel has apartheid" really cheapens the struggle of Black South Africans. Is this something a Black South African who suffered under apartheid and is intimately familiar with the current occupied Palestine told you, or are you the Black South African yourself?
- devcpp 13y agoI'll answer for him. Neither, I read about the apartheid from reliable sources and I know the situation but also read about statistics to make sure I'm not being unfair to either side. But what about the people who say "Israel has apartheid"? Did you ask how they can claim that? Or do you just assume that they are/have met South Africans who lived under the Apartheid?
- carlob 13y agoI didn't say 'Israel has apartheid'. I said that some Israeli commenters have compared the situation to apartheid. I used the verb border to be specific. There is a whole wikipedia page on the argument [1] if you want to know more about it. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analogy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analog...
- devcpp 13y agoSorry, I supposed that gadders quoted you accurately due to the quotes around "Israel has apartheid". I apologize. I'll edit my reply to maintain the legitimacy of the question.
- thwest 13y agoThese are different kinds of statements that require different kinds of knowledge. Israel clearly has two categories of citizens within its borders defined by tribal distinctions (race/religion). Whether this is formally 'apartheid' is an arguement worth having, since we can look at the UN definition and Israel's actions and have a meaningful discussion from an external perspective. Comparing the subjectivities of the lives lived under the two regimes necessitates experiential knowledge that is most likely lacking in this audience. I don't find oppression olympics arguments to be fruitful. The moral calculus of today's actions does not depend on the price paid in South Africa, The Congo, The American South, or in Revolutionary China.