5 ms·
> "Are U.S. citizens routinely arrested and placed in re-education by labor camps for a year without a trial?" No, people are just sent to Gitmo to be waterboa
by belorn 13y ago
> "Are U.S. citizens routinely arrested and placed in re-education by labor camps for a year without a trial?"
No, people are just sent to Gitmo to be waterboarded and held indefinite without a trial. They don't even care the nationality of where you come from.
- rayiner 13y agoThis is not true. Even US citizens capptured in Afghanistan fighting for the Taliban were transferred out of gitmo.
- epsylon 13y agoBut non-US citizens can liberally have their basic human rights denied. 12 years after 9/11. That's the land of the free for you. (Looking at how Bradley Manning was treated even shows that US citizens aren't treated much better. Being denied a lawyer and confined to solitary cells for months is not much different from torture.)
- DannoHung 13y agoManning was a member of the Army. You give up a significant number of rights and freedoms as a US citizen when you become a member of the armed forces. Which is not to say that it is right, but that it is legal.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoAt this point, American law is completely corrupt. Who gives a damn about it? What they've done to Bradley Manning isn't right, at all.
- jvictor118 13y agoBradley Manning was a member of the Armed Forces who released classified information to the public. What planet are you living on that his prosecution is unwarranted?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWhat planning are you living on where physical and psychological torture is a warranted response to breaking military law?
- lhc- 13y agoProsecution would be warranted. Indefinite detainment and torture is never warranted, especially for a US citizen.
- mpyne 13y agoAnd also, Manning wasn't denied a lawyer, even in his first confinement facility. I remember this vividly because Manning's own lawyer was the one who admitted that Manning had joked about killing himself before being placed on prevention-of-suicide status...
- asynchronous13 13y agoExcept for Yasser Hamdi, it took them a few months before they realized he was a u.s. citizen.
- rgbrenner 13y agoAnd when they found out he was a US citizen (about 6 months after capture), he was transferred to military jails in Virginia and South Carolina. He was in the system for a total of 3 years, and then in exchange for renouncing his US citizenship and agreeing to travel restrictions, etc, he was released and deported to Saudi Arabia where he grew up. Note the phrasing, he wasn't 'transferred' to Saudi Arabia, he was released, and given a plane ticket home. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaser_Esam_Hamdi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaser_Esam_Hamdi
- rayiner 13y agoHamdi was in Guantanamo for less than two months (Feb. 11 to April 5, 2002) while his legal status was sorted out. Considering he was caught in Afghanistan fighting for the Taliban, I'd put that in the "a win for the republic" column.
- belorn 13y agoThere is a whole article on wikipedia on the subject. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_detainees_at_Guantanamo_Bay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_detainees_at_Guantana... That said, US citizens has been sent to gitmo. They might been transferred out of there at a later time, but there is no denying that it happened. Then we have people like José Padilla who was held for several years without a trial, and only after major pressure from civil groups was he transferred to a civilian court. Being indefinite held without a trial until political pressure pushes the issues to the breaking point does not exactly paint a great picture.
- rayiner 13y agoThe article says that "The United States Department of Defense acknowledges holding 99 American citizens captured in Afghanistan, during the 'war on terror', and one of them was held, for a time, in Guantanamo." It continues: "But although Yasser Hamdi was born in the USA, he was raised in Saudi Arabia, and Joint Task Force Guantanamo counter-terrorism analysts did not realize he was an American." Your original comment was: "No, people are just sent to Gitmo to be waterboarded and held indefinite without a trial. They don't even care the nationality of where you come from." They obviously care, which is why the American citizens were either transferred out or never sent there in the first place, despite being caught fighting in Afghanistan.