3 ms·
Yeah, the secret of Costco is that they don't hire MBAs. If you actually want to go learn Costco's "secrets" of their basic business model, inventory managemen
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Yeah, the secret of Costco is that they don't hire MBAs.
If you actually want to go learn Costco's "secrets" of their basic business model, inventory management and staffing, go read Megan Mcardle's article comparing them to walmart:
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/11/26/why-can-t-walmart-be-more-like-costco.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/11/26/why-can-t-w...
Sadly, the "secret" of $SUCCESSFUL_COMPANY is almost always far more boring than we'd like. I really wish there was a news source that would actually write articles like this which discuss staffing levels, supply chain management and the like.
- ebbv 13y agoThat piece seems wildly insincere and misses the point, as does anything that just compares Wal Mart to Costco. Usually what people compare is Sam's Club to Costco. Sam's Club is the direct Costco competitor that is also owned by the Waltons. Of course Wal Mart is a different beast than Costco, everybody knows that. But that doesn't mean that Wal Mart couldn't treat its employees better. If anything the facts of McArdle's piece prove that point. (They are making plenty of profit, a lot of which could be reinvested in employees.)
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIt's not obvious to Matt Yglesias, to whom McArdle was responding. http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/11/26/walmart_wages_they_could_be_higher.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/11/26/walmart_wages...
- VLM 13y agoThat was an interesting article, thank you. Its a fact packed article and I assume the facts listed are true, although given later comments I do wonder. However her opinion "But Walmart is not just a poor man's Costco." strikes me as being exactly opposite both in examination and analysis of the facts she provides and personal experience. She then spent most of the rest of the article explaining how reality is the exact opposite. Maybe this is a legendary epic editing mistake and she meant to write "Walmart is just a poor man's Costco." but the editing and/or ad sales team made her change it or perhaps just an honest mistake. As a market positioning technique all you need do is find the bottom of the barrel, like Walmart, and position yourself as 10% better. Ta Da instant free positive press. You can make a 5000 word article about it, but this TLDR summary is just as good. I also thought the juxtaposition of the article vs the delivery mechanism was weird. This is a website full of chewing gum for the mind. Linkbait. "Your Tango Finding Nemo: The 10 Most Ridiculous Nicknames For Self-Love". So they're intentionally aiming for the shallow end of the socio-economic pool. And thats perfectly OK. Weekly World News readers and high school dropouts need websites too, the world is big enough that everyone doesn't have to visit HN. However the article author is incredibly condescending to the website's audience and spends a lot of time making fun of their concerns and distancing herself and her twitter feed from what she apparently views as lower class scum, which probably would sound about right in an Economist article (LOL I looked and she does in fact write for the Economist LOL) but why you'd put someone like that on the Daily Beast, which kinda puts the lower in "lower class", mystifies me.
- calinet6 13y agoThis is bullshit disguised as economics. It's an MBA's analysis of why they're not allowed in the club, and it's because "it's not cool enough for us." Costco follows TQM: their business model is integrative and process-based, and takes into account the quality of their product, market, shopper experience, employee experience, and management. This is key. It cannot be ignored or glossed-over or simplified, and any doing so is indicative of an ignorance of the process. There isn't a lot available about Costco's internal process (that I can find with some cursory googling), but TQM is based on W. Edwards Deming's theories about factory quality, applied in Japan to bring back their entire economy after WWII: https://asq.org/learn-about-quality/total-quality-management/overview/deming-points.html https://asq.org/learn-about-quality/total-quality-management... -- I've found this single article which sums up Costco's successful use of it: http://costcoteam3.blogspot.com/2009/06/quality-control.html http://costcoteam3.blogspot.com/2009/06/quality-control.html From the article: "The true definition of quality control is the stabilization and maintenance of a process to produce consistent output. The key to Costco's ability to maintain their low prices and quality is because of good wages and benefits." This is an astute recognition of the importance of the workforce in the quality control process. This is, quite simply, the truth. The blog post also goes into other use of TQM and process control, including statistical analysis of transportation, use of data on a large scale, and using product quality control methods to ensure good final consumer satisfaction. This is all essential to quality, which is essential to their business model. You can look into details of all aspects of their business, but they will always be secondary to their overarching TQM model—everything is inherited from that. Asking for details about this is like asking what type of screws were used on the Space Shuttle and claiming that's why it actually got to space. This is not simply a coincidence of market position and product segmentation. It is all a deliberate, controlled process that is repeatable. Most importantly, other businesses can use all of these concepts to also get a repeatable, predictable process-controlled output. To me, this is not boring or trivial at all. It is paramount to the success of the organization, and an important paradigm shift for all American business. This is something you need to pay attention to. TQM, and more fundamentally Deming are things you should look into and understand, because they are more correct and provable than your standard run-of-the-mill boring old business theory. Even software companies can reap the rewards in process theory and management theory. The secret of this successful company is actually different, and it's on a high level. You can't just reduce it because you don't like the high level part. Pay attention.
- vampirechicken 13y agoFor me, It would have been a better article if it had maintained Sam's Club as a focus, rather than switching to Walmart after comparing shopping club employee wages.