4 ms·
The first question will be which American citizen was harmed, and what was the harm. This will be extremely difficult to answer since all aspects of the progra
by snowwrestler 13y ago
The first question will be which American citizen was harmed, and what was the harm.
This will be extremely difficult to answer since all aspects of the program are top secret, so it is impossible to know whose data has been accessed.
In addition, merely accessing data at rest does not really do any harm. You'd really need a U.S. citizen who you can prove has been wrongfully arrested or harassed as a direct result of their data being accessed in this way.
Finally, there is a real risk that the Supreme Court (this one in particular) will defer to Congress, as it tends to do on matters of war and self-defense.
Simply put, the far, far better option here is to petition Congress. They will respond directly if the public pressure gets high enough.
- aroch 13y ago> The first question will be which American citizen was harmed, and what was the harm. A violation of Fourth or Fifth amendment rights constitutes a real harm done to a person as far as the courts are concerned. >In addition, merely accessing data at rest does not really do any harm. You'd really need a U.S. citizen who you can prove has been wrongfully arrested or harassed as a direct result of their data being accessed in this way. As far as I'm aware, this isn't a requirement...If you can prove the programs were overly broad, did in fact collect information on citizens illegally (which, by all accounts has already been established as of 2011) you're good. >Simply put, the far, far better option here is to petition Congress. They will respond directly if the public pressure gets high enough. Well, yes...But OP is specifically about the courts