3 ms·
Flagged because Windows-bashing is dull.
by gaius 18y ago
Flagged because Windows-bashing is dull.
- anigbrowl 18y agoDidn't strike me as Windows-bashing. I'd object too - if the university wants to use only certain tools, they can provide them (and have the responsibility for being able to load & export Excel data with OpenOffice). If the student wants to use other but equally powerful tools, it's not the university's business. I suspect this was dreamed up by accountants rather than faculty.
- neilc 18y agoif the university wants to use only certain tools, they can provide them If you don't want to buy the tools needed to take the class, then don't take the class. Universities don't provide free textbooks, for example. Of course, it would be better if the university provided the required tools or offered more flexibility, but I agree with the parent poster that this is not an interesting subject.
- anigbrowl 18y agoWhat I meant to say (but did so poorly) was that requiring a certain software platform is like requiring certain brands of paper and pencils to be used for note taking. I draw a distinction between course materials and the tools used to study them. Using Excel spreadsheets as teaching/submission materials is fine by me, but it's not their business how the student deals with that, eg by using alternative software. I don't see why students should be required to only use Windows, any more than why they would be required to only use Dell laptops. FWIW I'm happily using windows right now...by choice.
- gaius 18y agoUntil you get to the point at which students work needs to be assessed. In most CS courses if it doesn't run first time on the prof's machine, that's an automatic fail.