4 ms·
Is he so great? His books are great I hear, but he's antisemetic: He supports BDS. I haven't decided if I want to read his books anyway. Divorce the artist fro
by ars 13y ago
Is he so great? His books are great I hear, but he's antisemetic: He supports BDS.
I haven't decided if I want to read his books anyway. Divorce the artist from the art.
(And please don't tell me that BDS is not antisemetic because that's nonsense - just look at who the founders were.)
- mercurial 13y agoI didn't know Banks personally, unfortunately, but I challenge you to find a single anti-semitic statement he made. As for BDS, I wasn't familiar with it until 5 minutes ago, but it seems to be a group calling for a non-violent boycott of Israel. I have a hard imagining how you can paint everybody who supports them as antisemitic. If you want a shortcut into his politics, I suggest you read Dead Air.
- ars 13y ago> but it seems to be a group calling for a non-violent boycott of Israel They are calling for the delegitimization of Israel as a country. > how you can paint everybody who supports them as antisemitic I can't. I don't know him, but if you are going to publicly support a group it behooves you to look into them first. Thanks for the mention of Dead Air - have you read it? I'm not familiar with UK politics - why is he so mad at Tony Blair?
- Argorak 13y ago> They are calling for the delegitimization of Israel as a country. [Citation needed] While there is a fair bit of criticism flying around that argues one way or the other that thought through, the goals of the group could mean just that, there is no statement from the group itself. So they are certainly not 'calling'. It is a very controversial group, I give you that, but it is not as clear cut as you make it seem to be. I agree that I wouldn't touch it with a stick, but that still doesn't make it as easy you try to make it seem.
- mercurial 13y ago> They are calling for the delegitimization of Israel as a country. They are? They don't exactly advertise that on their website. Even if they were, it's like saying "Belgium is not a real country". It's orthogonal to one's feelings wrt Belgian nationals. Unless you think Stephen Hawking, another BDS supporter, dons a balaclava at night to beat up his kippa-bearing neighbours. I have read Dead Air. And it's pretty easy to understand why he would be pissed off at Blair. If your country was headed by a compulsive liar, whose lies had brought your country in a protracted, costly, pointless war, you'd be pissed too.
- glogla 13y agoNot every critique of Israel is antisemitism, the same way that critique of Mugabe doesn't make you racist. Pretending that it is so is one of the traditional "arguments" of US far right, and I don't think it has place any in reasonable discussion. EDIT: just in case you're wondering why the downvote.
- ars 13y ago> Not every critique of Israel is antisemitism Most are. People and organization who make a point of criticizing every injustice they know about can make that distinction. But for virtually everyone else criticism of Israel is just thinly veiled antisemitism. And pretending it's not also doesn't have any place in reasonable discussion. It's especially obvious from counties that criticize Israel for kicking out and/or not allowing back in Palestinians - and simultaneously have expelled thousands for Jews from their own lands. (Or from people who know about it, and yet don't also criticize the Arab countries.) I've heard rebuttals along the lines of "I don't have to criticize everyone for my claims to be valid". But when the only county they focus on is Israel the true feelings are obvious.
- darkarmani 13y ago> But for virtually everyone else criticism of Israel is just thinly veiled antisemitism. And pretending it's not also doesn't have any place in reasonable discussion. If criticizing Israel is the de facto definition of antisemitism, maybe antisemitism isn't as bad as i though?
- ars 13y agoCriticizing Israel is the de facto symptom of antisemitism. It's the "socially accepted" version. Because, rarely it really is just criticizing of Israel - but that's rare. So people claim "I'm also one of the rare ones".
- darkarmani 13y ago> It's the "socially accepted" version. Because, rarely it really is just criticizing of Israel - but that's rare. So people claim "I'm also one of the rare ones". What? It's very easy to find something to criticize Israel for, so I don't understand this reasoning. Either you want to stop all conversations that are any bit negative about Israel, or your honestly believe that everyone is an antisemite.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoDid he ever do anything bad to Israel? Did Israel ever do anything good to him? As you know from history, if both answers are "no", then he's not antisemitic, he just happen to have an opinion.
- casiotone 13y agoLovely bit of hasbara but you're not convincing anyone. Anti-zionism is not anti-semitism.