4 ms·
It's not all or nothing, obviously, but many people's dietary choices (especially those who consider themselves most health-conscious) go far, far beyond anythi
by pron 13y ago
It's not all or nothing, obviously, but many people's dietary choices (especially those who consider themselves most health-conscious) go far, far beyond anything that's supported by science. My claim is that most dietary choices beyond a reasonable intake of calories and more or less "normal" food is magical thinking and worse -- it's pseudoscience. This includes what we know about human physiology. We know how some systems work, but we don't know much about how they interact. Suppose fiber helps to move waste through the intestines. But does it have other effects as well? Is it good overall? And suppose it is good overall -- just how good is it? Is it even worth the effort of consciously increasing your green vegetable consumption by 10%? This last point is the crucial one, because I'm trying to show that when it comes to food, some people actively change their behavior based on conjectures, or little evidence.
BTW, what I like most about John Ioannidis's work is that he not only proved theoretically that most medical research is false, but he showed it empirically: He showed that a large percentage of papers in the best regarded medical journal turned out to either be completely false, or to have a much reduced effect-size. Some of these papers suggested practices that, at the time, were considered "probably good" choices, and have since been shown to be anything but.
What I was saying about purity had nothing to do with psychoanalysis. Not all psychology and anthropology is psychoanalysis, and I suggest you take a look at Haidt's research. At the very least, it's thought provoking.
Lastly, I'm not taking a hyper-rational stance. I've long ago realized that I, like all people, am far from rational. I am superstitious myself, and about stranger things than food. I just think that the rise of the food religion among the educated liberal elite is interesting. I am very much interested in the history of religion and mysticism, and I always find it fascinating how magic works its way back into our lives -- contrary to Max Weber's assertion -- no matter our background. Haidt's theory of values is one especially interesting framework through which to examine this phenomenon.
- doktrin 13y ago> BTW, what I like most about John Ioannidis's work is that he not only proved theoretically that most medical research is false "Proved" is being thrown about a bit liberally in connection with Ioannidis' work. It's certainly in dispute [1] Either way, it seems your central point has a number of flaws. What you are attributing to superstition (e.g. consuming more leafy greens) is in fact more often than not rational decision making based on admittedly limited information. Will the consumption of vegetables ultimately improve ones health? I don't know, let's take a more specific example. For instance, take someone interested in positively affecting their likelihood of developing diabetes. A quick google search turns up a study that notes a correlation between increased vegetable intake and a reduced risk of diabetes[2]. Of course, increasing intake of green vegetables may mean a decrease in some other substance. Another quick search turns up a research study documenting a link between increased fructose consumption and insulin resistance [3]. Thus, if I were hypothetically interested in positively affecting my insulin response, it would be quite logical to increase my consumption of green vegetables while decreasing my intake of sugar. Is this course of action wrong? Possibly. However, it's certainly rational and not exactly "superstitious". You've defined the term so loosely as to encapsulate even such things as making rational decisions based on limited information. That is certainly not what superstitious really means. Certainly, someone who refuses to change their dietary habits despite ample refuting evidence could be classified as superstitious, but that's not a distinction you have made. [1] http://www.technologyreview.com/view/510126/the-statistical-puzzle-over-how-much-biomedical-research-is-wrong/ http://www.technologyreview.com/view/510126/the-statistical-... [2] http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2010-08/bmj-glv081810.php http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2010-08/bmj-glv081810... [3] http://www.nutritionandmetabolism.com/content/2/1/5 http://www.nutritionandmetabolism.com/content/2/1/5
- pron 13y ago> What you are attributing to superstition (e.g. consuming more leafy greens) is in fact more often than not rational decision making based on admittedly limited information. Perhaps I have not made my case clearly. Magical thinking has two parts: the first is being wrong (although that's not essential for magical thinking; it can be accidentally true); the second -- and this is what distinguishes magical thinking and superstition from mere false belief -- is its motivation to action. People believe many things that are wrong, but superstition is the false belief that changes their behavior. My claim is that healthy food falls under the category of superstition, or magical thinking, because people so readily turn what you call limited information into action. What we may think of as "classical superstition", say fear of black cats, was also based on limited information. I'm sure there was plenty of evidence to suggest black cats are harbingers of bad luck. So, fearing black cats could be classified as rational action. But fear of black cats, same as the healthy-food religion, is superstition precisely because it is a belief people accept based on lower standards of evidence than they would in other aspects of their lives, and at the same time motivates them to take action. Why? Because they want to believe it. It makes them either afraid or hopeful.
- doktrin 13y ago> I'm sure there was plenty of evidence to suggest black cats are harbingers of bad luck. There were university publications on black cats being harbingers of bad luck? While it's hard to juxtapose what constituted an 'equivalent' level evidence during what are otherwise radically different historical time periods, this claim strikes me as stretching the analogy quite far. > But fear of black cats, same as the healthy-food religion, is superstition precisely because it is a belief people accept based on lower standards of evidence than they would in other aspects of their lives Multiple academic findings corroborating each other is typically seen as enough evidence upon which to base action. If not, then what constitutes adequate evidence? Also, it would be helpful if you could point out aspects of peoples lives in which they generally behave according to your definition of rationality, or in which they maintain a 'high' standard of evidence.
- 13y ago