4 ms·
As a predominantly Asia-resident member of this community who has passed through many of the countries I find this post rather interesting. I suggest changing t
by contingencies 13y ago
As a predominantly Asia-resident member of this community who has passed through many of the countries I find this post rather interesting. I suggest changing the title to make the subject more obvious - I nearly skipped it.
However, I am going to be honest: I think the horrible truth here is that there is no 'startup scene' in most of these countries, no 'serviced apartments' in the places 'to meet the post people'. The claimed contents themselves betray a distinct lack of understanding of the host cultures through an American perspective.
Quite simply, these products look far too much like smoke and mirrors with external cultural baggage to boot.
As someone who as actually run a startup in China, for instance, the contents are a joke. No mention of the most important areas of consideration, overemphasis of things that are irrelevant.
So what the hell is this? They are hiring. Job description: "Find a few real estate people. Ask what’s the best place for a new business to locate." ... subtext: publish that as fact.
Come on... this is lowly. Just because you have some money to spam-market quick-e-books with doesn't mean you are the arbiter of truth. Hire a real writer, do some real research, and be honest about it. Without quality, there is little point in publishing.
Fail.
- mkress 13y agoThere doesn't have to be a startup scene in all of the countries. The books were written for entrepreneurship, not Valley-level startup scenes. Eiter way, have you checked out write ups of the recent Echelon event in Singapore (http://e27.co/echelon/)or http://e27.co/echelon/)or that 500 startups just set up a fund only for SEAsia countries? As far as the spam-market quick-e-books comment, I'm pretty sure it was the absolute opposite of that. Did you read that after a year and a half of hard work he released these? I don't see these books as a fail at all, but instead a step forward to good, actionable information that is useful to help bring and grow entrepreneurship to Asia. I would love to hear what's important to you as I'm currently running a startup in Thailand and would love to learn more about all the countries, especially China. Why don't you offer some advice as to what you see ont he most important areas of consideration and what is overemphasized?
- contingencies 13y agoBasic stuff: Stability, system of law, contrast available legal structures, different types of taxation, financial services, visa/immigration, shipping/logistics concerns, internal geographic breakdown, indicative service costings (utilities, advertising, etc.), nature of local human resources market, notable commercial events/tradeshows, trends over time with all of the above, etc.
- detst 13y agoThose things are covered and if you would have taken the time to do even a cursory review before writing your baseless dismissal you would have seen this. It's clear this is an evolving project. I don't believe Derek Sivers would do a project like you making it out to be and I don't think you have any basis to think he is, even if you don't know who he is. Just to quickly address some things where you've missed the point: these are entrepreneurs' guides; these are targeted at an American and other non-Asian markets so it's important to answer questions from that perspective, regardless if you think they're irrelevant (you can't know what's irrelevant until someone tells you or you learn from experience); it's amusing that the "contents are a joke" when they address the things you have asked for. And from above: > Come on... this is lowly. Just because you have some money to spam-market quick-e-books with doesn't mean you are the arbiter of truth. Hire a real writer, do some real research, and be honest about it. Without quality, there is little point in publishing. Fail. Go look at the content before before making such claims ("lowly...spam...without quality") and advising them on their methods. After you've done that, how about focusing on the content? Sorry for the tone but I can't stand these types of off-base dismissals and ending it with "fail" is just the icing on the cake. Derek Sivers is a respected member of the community that just spent the last nearly two years of his life on this and deserves better than these as the top comments on his announcement.
- contingencies 13y agoAre you suggesting that the table of contents does not reflect the contents? I suppose that's possible.