3 ms·
This is rubbish. Let us consult a dead Prussian who had a great deal to say on the topic: "We see, therefore, that war is not merely an act of policy but a tru
by angersock 13y ago
This is rubbish. Let us consult a dead Prussian who had a great deal to say on the topic:
"We see, therefore, that war is not merely an act of policy but a true political instrument, a continuation of political intercourse carried on with other means. What remains peculiar to war is simply the peculiar nature of its means." -- Carl von Clausewitz
Now, the past decade of war has been against enemies which do not have the authority, power, or will to be dealt with politically. The obvious question, then, is how we can be fighting a war--we are going after the criminals that hit us, no?
Even a defense wherein we say "Aha! But the Taliban and Saddam regime were opposed to us, politically!" is flawed, for we had successfully conducted combat operations against their regular forces and won by any reasonable definition of the phrase. We now find ourselves in a long and bloody occupation---for that is what this is, and an occupation is not a war.
To be even more blunt about this, we cannot simply ascribe the bombing of an Afghan village as an unfortunate side-effect of total war.
We are not engaged in total war, we are not engaging an enemy which has hills and manufacturing capacity worth our bombs and weapons--this is no Dresden or Hiroshima or Nagasaki.
Hiding behind "War is hell" at the very least requires us to be engaged in an honest war, and this we are not.
- theorique 13y agoI think we're using the instrument of 'war' for an end which it is not suited for. As you point out, we're not engaged in total war, at least not any more. The lines are clearer in that case: kill or capture all soldiers, do your best not to kill civilians but recognize that mistakes are made. And maybe that was the case in 2001-2002, but this has morphed into a sort of hazy nation-building / police-action kind of thing. But the tools and methods more suited to total war are still being employed, with the same brutal side-effects.
- angersock 13y agoMinor nit-pick: total war is exactly about killing civilians. It is about the total mobilization of your nation's resources and assets--military and otherwise--in support of a violent enforcement of your political policies. Civilians are fair game, because they are assumed to be working in direct support of your opponents war-making capabilities. That said, I submit that we were never engaged with an opponent capable of conducting meaningful total war against our nation, and as such any loss of civilian life is unjustifiable.