10 ms·
The NSA slides are highly damaging to American service providers, thus they are trying to be as forceful as possible in these statements. There are already Euro
by guelo 13y ago
The NSA slides are highly damaging to American service providers, thus they are trying to be as forceful as possible in these statements. There are already European government officials calling for the discontinuation of American services and for the development of European alternatives. Making the matter worse is American official's arrogant short-sighted reassurances that the surveillance is for foreigners only. As the NSA called it "our home-field advantage", that these dominant global Internet companies are located here, could quickly be lost thanks to the hubris of our government.
- RWeaver 13y agoDefinitely, I'm on the lookout for any kind of service that operates in a country with transparent law enforcement and accountability. I trust Google not to share my sensitive information (product strategies, negotiating positions) with competitors on request, I can't trust some random agent who knows he won't be held accountable if he looks up and sends that information to his cousin. There's the potential here to 'disrupt' the whole of silicon valley.
- techsupporter 13y ago> I'm on the lookout for any kind of service that operates in a country with transparent law enforcement and accountability. And Diogenes thought he had it bad when looking for an honest man. That the U.S. did this is completely despicable and I'm furious at my government--especially, the guy I voted for who ran on a platform of stopping this--for continuing to pull these stunts. I look out over the panoply of countries with "modern, well-formed" legal systems, and I keep seeing the same abuses: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/2027377.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/2027377.stm - "The [United Kingdom] National Technical Assistance Centre (NTAC) will decrypt computer data and intercepted internet and e-mail traffic as part of a drive against cyber-crime..." http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/constitutional-concerns-german-intelligence-under-fire-for-spying-on-parliamentarians-a-812511.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/constitutional-c... - "German Intelligence Under Fire For Spying on Parliamentarians..." http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/every-click-you-make-theyll-be-watching-20120711-21wfg.html http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/every-click... - "[The] telephone and internet data of every Australian will be retained for up to two years and intelligence agencies would be given increased access to social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter..." Plus, if you're a foreigner (e.g. an American using Australian services), what incentive does the "other" country have to care about you? No one has complained, in this whole debate, about one country spying on the citizens of another country. This uproar happened because the U.S. NSA admitted to gathering data on domestic people under the guise of doing "foreign" surveillance. Maybe I'm just getting too cynical.
- RWeaver 13y agoThe data retention laws in Australia haven't been approved yet to my knowledge, but as part of the Echelon program they're not safe either. Although at least they announced the intention to make those changes to let democracy work and, and didn't use gag orders for spurious reasons. I'm expecting something in Europe (ThePirateBay crew seem pretty trustworthy), or some self sufficient island? (New Zealand?)
- te_chris 13y agoNope, the processes and safeguards around what the GCSB and SIS can do in NZ are laughably relaxed and just became more so. The GCSB were the agency who fucked up Kim Dotcom's case, after all.
- aragot 13y ago> Definitely, I'm on the lookout for any kind of service that operates in a country with transparent law enforcement and accountability. Being European, I'm looking for services which operate in my home country. I prefer to be spied where I'm a citizen, because US clearly only protects the privacy of its own citizen, and because it is illusional that intelligence services be transparent. However, there is no such thing as a european company running cloud services for email, rss, file storage and social network: Not even talking about dismissing american-funded strat-ups, all the supposedly European services are run under a .com website, and this extension puts them under american trade and penal laws - We've had this example of a piracy UK website run by UK citizen be trialled in US, where the defendant knew no-one, for the domain was in .com. Note that I would trust a cloud service registered in my ophome country and in .se, because they have proper forms of government. Who's up to start such a company? I'd give them big money to keep my records home.
- magicalist 13y agoThis is not correct. You and your site are certainly not subject to "american trade and penal laws" just because a .com registered address directs to your server. They can seize your domain name, but that's it.
- aragot 13y agohttp://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/jul/03/us-anti-piracy-extradition-prosecution http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/jul/03/us-anti-pir... They can extrade the person: "As long as a website's address ends in .com or .net, if it is implicated in the spread of pirated US-made films, TV or other media it is a legitimate target to be closed down or targeted for prosecution"
- mnordhoff 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FRA_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FRA_law .se, huh?
- cmelbye 13y agoOne doesn't just develop alternatives to Google, Apple, etc. It takes more than just an official calling for it to make that happen.
- aragot 13y agoWe're talking about stock consumer services which should be commoditized, at the very least. With AtMail, The Old Reader, Diaspora, there is already open source software to cover most our vital needs, and it is not impossible to develop cloud services in other continents. I wouldn't be surprised of a sweeping European law saying "For the safety of European Intellectual properties, it is forbidden for businesses to store their email in Gmail". The game is to explain the WTO that this is not protectionism, and given the present NSA leaks, it only makes it easier.
- guelo 13y agoIt just depends on how much they want it. China has built decent knock-offs for search engines, email, social network, etc. without much trouble. And as a bonus they've helped grow their software industry.
- stackedmidgets 13y agoAll they really have to do is refuse to enforce American IP. New copycat competitors will emerge immediately.
- edwardunknown 13y agoThese slides? http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/07/the-real-nsa-scandal-the-horrible-slides/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/07/t...; They look like they were made with MS Paint. CNET and James Clapper says this is all bullshit. Maybe we should stop drawing conclusions about a story that is developing and extremely foggy until it clears up a little more?
- nostromo 13y agoIf you have ever seen a government presentation before, you might find that the lack of design makes them more credible, not less.
- quackerhacker 13y agoI agree, less money on the power point, and more on the Utah data center[0]...and just for laughs, lets not forget Ryan Fogle[1], the CIA agent captured in russia. [0]http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter&#x...; [1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/14/ryan-fogle-cia_n_3271390.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/14/ryan-fogle-cia_n_32...
- glesica 13y agoThe comment about MS Paint is one of the stupidest, most naive things I have ever seen on HN. Have you every worked for a company or organization outside of SV? Nobody gives a shit what your slides look like in the real world. Sure, ideally slides wouldn't look like crap, but since most "normal" people don't even notice, nobody tries very hard.
- monkmartinez 13y agoEd Bott on CNET says its all bullshit, ok we should all just go home then. excuse me while I http://trololololololololololo.com http://trololololololololololo.com
- mpyne 13y agoEh, I'll say this much, the design really does scream "GOVERNMENT PRESENTATION" all over it. Even the issues about the slight differences between WaPo and Guardian variants of the slides are easy to explain with different versions of Microsoft Office (or even using LibreOffice to try to open).
- kiba 13y agoWe should give foreigners rights that Americans enjoy. If American enjoys 4th amendment protection, so can foreigners. That mean you can't spy on foreigner without getting a warrant from an open court, rather than secret courts with secret ruling. Edit: I am not arguing that foreigners should receive welfare check and benefit from social programs. I am arguing that if they are targeted by the US government, they should be subjected to the same protection. There should be no special exception for anybody, because the special exception was used to justified the NSA spying program.
- bilbo0s 13y agoGood luck with that.
- carbocation 13y agoIs there a precedent for that? I don't mean to agree or disagree (though I am inclined to disagree, I admit, which is why I ask the question). By asking, though, I hope to see the advantages and disadvantages in a real-world situation.
- ihsw 13y agoUniversal jurisdiction[1] is a fairly new concept, and there definitely precedents. The Nuremburg trials are notably the first major application of jurisdiction over a distinctly separate, foreign and sovereign nation. Most things that qualify as precedents are predominantly rulings on genocide, crimes against humanity, extrajudicial executions, war crimes, torture and forced disappearances. The impact of universal jurisdiction is not simple, in fact it flies in the face of Westphalian soverignty[2] in the sense that it destroys it utterly, potentially disrupting over four centuries of precedent and denying nations' inherent right to self-determination. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_jurisdiction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_jurisdiction [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westphalian_sovereignty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westphalian_sovereignty
- carbocation 13y agoGreat post. I think that there is a distinction to be drawn here, though. Nuremberg essentially applied penalties for rights violations to people of a foreign, sovereign nation. The proposal in the GP comment is for new rights–not new responsibilities–to be granted to people of a foreign, sovereign nation. So I appreciate the background you have provided, and I want to springboard from there to draw a distinction, and to see if there is any precedent for something even more similar.
- mortehu 13y agoIt should be noted that the European Economic Area is currently implementing the Data Retention Directive[1], which in my opinion is worse for end-users than what the blogosphere is extrapolating from some dude's PowerPoint slides in this case. If you're using a US hosted service, there's nothing preventing you from deleting your data if it hasn't been subpoenaed already. European countries are starting to enforce a 6-24 month minimum retention period for traffic data. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Retention_Directive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Retention_Directive
- wslh 13y agoWe need to take a look at these companies' stocks in the next few weeks. It can be seen as malpractice from the shareholders perspective. What Google et al didn't take into account, being very short sighted, is the competitive advantage they lost unprotecting their customers information.