5 ms·
from my very basic understanding of EU privacy laws, the big win is that they treat everybody equally - the rules say what data you can retain, what data you ca
by notatoad 13y ago
from my very basic understanding of EU privacy laws, the big win is that they treat everybody equally - the rules say what data you can retain, what data you can't, and that's it. What really scares me about all this FISA and PRISM stuff is that they treat foreigners as essentially non-persons. They at least make some effort at pretending there's a due process for american citizens, but if you're a foreigner with your data on a system owned by a US company, you literally have no rights at all.
- aswanson 13y agoYeah, that attitude in the u.s. scares me; the labels we put on noncitizens. Those labels, I believe enabled our compliant media to sell that idiotic Iraq war to the public. I don't recall them tracking the Iraqi civilian deaths at all. I mean, after all, they weren't born in the u.s. so who cares, right?
- dnautics 13y agoit's merely formalizing the truth that because they can't vote, the government is not accountable to noncitizens. Do you seriously think that the European Union treats everyone within its borders equally? If that were the case, why are there the banlieues of Paris? Why does Italy treat african boat people so poorly? Why are there stateless individuals of Turkish descent in Germany?
- flexie 13y agoThat's a very good point - in the last months the world listened in on Americans debating whether drones can be used against Americans or just against us foreigners, as if we are worth less. Now we learn that the American government speculates that maybe foreigners don't deserve the same degree of privacy.
- mpyne 13y agoI hope this isn't new to you. Since day one the NSA has been legally limited to collection of data on foreigners. That part of it is nothing new. FBI is who handled domestic intelligence operations. While I don't like that attitude (and don't like it for the drone discussion either, or Gitmo), it's not at all anything new. I think the concept dates from the 1800s in fact
- Silhouette 13y agoWhat really scares me about all this FISA and PRISM stuff is that they treat foreigners as essentially non-persons. Something that struck me a while ago is that while most of the modern world talks about protecting "human rights", the ruling classes in the US always seem to talk about protecting things like "Constitutional rights" or "citizens' rights". I'm not sure what that says about their underlying attitude, but it can't be good. The trouble is, a lot of places have at least tendencies in the same direction, it's just hard to see them if you're a native and get to go in the "EU citizen" queue at customs or whatever it might be, so you don't see how others visiting your country are treated even from the moment they arrive. And since typically those outsiders have no direct influence on policy in places they visit, there is no natural political incentive for each country's government to treat them as much more than a source of revenue for the tourism/education/commercial sector. With the rise in modern times of ubiquitous international communications networks and relatively quick and easy physical travel between countries, unfortunately this seems to be a race to the bottom, with a lower bound determined only by the point at which people actually stop visiting/communicating with your country, which as a practical matter is going to be difficult for many people to do.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoWell, i've seen people avoid visiting USA thanks to airport security (and US airports in general). Insane visa requirements don't help either. In the age of internet it's actually easier to stop physically moving around.
- Silhouette 13y agoWell, i've seen people avoid visiting USA thanks to airport security In fact, you're talking to one right now. The way I look at it, there are many wonderful places in the world that I would like to visit one day, but I'm never going to make it to all of them in the one lifetime I get. I'd prefer to go to places where I will feel welcome and enjoy myself, not to places where the procedure on arrival or departure is going to make me feel like a criminal just for showing up. Of course, some people have jobs that require them to travel or have family living abroad or for many other reasons would need to make much greater sacrifices than I do if they were to give up flying. So I try not to assume that everyone else can vote with their wallets as easily as I can on this one.
- 7952 13y agoAnd the irony is that foreigners are increasingly being considered as targets fo prosecution without having set foot in the county.