3 ms·
Code, not laws. Most foreign governments are just as bad, just with fewer resources and often with less explicit protections for privacy. The ultimate solutio
by rdl 13y ago
Code, not laws.
Most foreign governments are just as bad, just with fewer resources and often with less explicit protections for privacy.
The ultimate solution would be to only use cloud servers which make verifiable technical claims about security and privacy to the level you require; otherwise, boycott the cloud.
I'm personally fine with Twitter as a publishing platform (and essentially treat my dm as "stuff which is too spammy for even an at reply".)
Facebook kind of skirts the line. It is really useful as both a way to get newsfeed updates and a messaging system. In the long run, I'd really need something like OTR to continue using messages.
My email is too private for me to want it on a cloud service without serious technical controls. No one offers this yet, so I self-host.
IM with OTR is ok for privacy, but sucks for traffic analysis still, and there are serious problems with OTR and mobile/multi client, still.
My password manager is too sensitive to live on public servers even with crypto, since I can't audit every single update to the package thoroughly enough. Same goes with "secure notes" (safe combos, etc). A belt and suspenders approach of both using crypto and maintaining access control on the file is about the best I can do so far; something like an HSM in the future.
Cellphones and voice (and presence/location) are the sacrifice I hate the most (along with finance, I guess). If I had a way to get analog one-way pager notifications of incoming messages and a wifi-tunneling tablet, I'd consider ditching cellphone entirely. This would be a moderately big deal to develop, though.
Ultimately anonymous ecash (chaumian blinded tokens or Zerocoin or something else) is the solution to financial privacy (probably not straight Bitcoin, since there will be a jihad against mixes, and without mixes, Bitcoin privacy is horrible.)
- polemic 13y agoNo no no. Firstly this is just an arms race between you and the most sophisticated, well resourced and technically savvy surveillance organisation that has ever existed. Secondly, this strategy might temporarily protect a tiny knowledgable fraction of the population, which is of no real consequence to society in general.
- jfoutz 13y agoYes, we all know who will win in an arms race between me and google.
- rdl 13y agoFortunately the same principles of physics and mathematics apply to both me and Google (and the #3 or #4 most powerful/smart organization, NSA). I trust science a lot more than I trust either every member of every organization to obey the law, or the law to remain both public and supportive of my interests.
- dnautics 13y agodon't be so sure. The NSA is probably far, far ahead in mathematics.
- rdl 13y agoAbsolutely true in 1970, but probably much less true now (they probably ARE experts in traffic analysis, though, since ~no one but intel agencies cares about that yet). Academia and commerce tend to surpass the government in every OTHER area where they participate, it's just that no one cared pre-70s. I don't think they're using their huge budget efficiently, just like every other government/military program. The bulk of their budget and effort is going to collection, mainly satellites, physical installations, staffing for those, etc. Judging by what I've seen of USG security, their COMSEC side (defense) is actually comparatively weaker than best practices in most of the high-end civilian world. Their only saving grace is a focus on physical separation and hardware implementations; otherwise they'd be totally pwned, and they seem to be moving "into the cloud" which will lose their their existing advantages. And, if they had a magic way to factor or whatever, it would be so highly classified (like Enigma break in WW2)that they could never use it on anything which wasn't totally justifiable through other plausible means, and of such incredible value (like "killing OBL" or higher), that I can act as if they can't factor.
- dnautics 13y agoI'm pretty sure the NSA has an active program to recruit high-level strictly theoretical mathematicians specializing in algebra and algebraic analysis (typically at the undergrad level). Agree that the US's COMSEC is degrading, rapidly. As is the USN's nuke reactor program. Sigh.
- Zigurd 13y ago> this is just an arms race For encryption, that's not really true. If armor were like encryption then one inch of armor would be a billion times more resistant than half an inch. The strength of encryption can be calculated to be on a cosmic scale infeasible to crack.
- polemic 13y agoThe theory of it doesn't really matter. How can you share encryption keys securely if all system is traffic is transparent? Ultimately, You might be able to temporarily reduce the attack surface, but you will always be massively mismatched. The point is, a technical solution is a band aid solution for a technical elite happy to live half outside of "normal" society. The only way to convey similar protections on the rest of the population is through strong legislation.
- Zigurd 13y agoKey exchange can also be secured. Ephemeral keys can make it difficult to sustain an attack on key storage at endpoints. The everyday use of strong encryption would be a lot more than a "band aid." It would mean securing our right to be secure in our documents against any attack, legal or technical. It would become a right any individual could enforce against all comers.
- polemic 13y agoThis is exactly what I mean about an arms race. If an agency is legally entitled to access private keys, for example, through legalised hacking of your home computer via backdoors installed by cooperative corporations, you're back to square one. If the network controllers make the so-called metadata of who talked to who and when, they've got a heck of lot of data to start with. If the control as much computer power and as much of the world expertise on crypography as some people claim, maybe they can break crypto in ways that appear mathematically unlikely now. Arms race. You cannot win with purely technical means when you fundamentally lack control over the technology.