5 ms·
He was very far from turning American into anything, even more into a Stalinist dictatorship which denies basic rights to life and liberty, routinely starves of
by smsm42 13y ago
He was very far from turning American into anything, even more into a Stalinist dictatorship which denies basic rights to life and liberty, routinely starves off, murders and imprisons millions of citizens and has no concept of human rights to speak of. He may falsely accused some people of being communist sympathizers, and he may cost some people that associated with communists their jobs (to appreciate it, think about current Congress discovering there are multiple Al Qaeda agents in all levels of government and trying to investigate it, and people answering "I'm taking the Fifth" when asked if they have had any ties with Al Qaeda). But nothing even close to turning America into the thing he most despised - i.e. Stalinist USSR.
- anonyfuss 13y agoIt's scary to see how many closet fascists are here on ycombinator.
- smsm42 13y agoPlease look up the word "fascist" in the dictionary next time before using it.
- anonyfuss 13y agoYou seem to need it more. Let me help: "n. an adherent of fascism or similar right-wing authoritarian". Sounds about right. Mussolini said: "Fascism, sitting on the right, could also have sat on the mountain of the center ... These words in any case do not have a fixed and unchanged meaning: they do have a variable subject to location, time and spirit. We don't give a damn about these empty terminologies and we despise those who are terrorized by these words" Quoting Robert Paxton's "The Anatomy of Fascism": facism is "... a form of political behavior marked by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation, or victimhood and by compensatory cults of unity, energy, and purity, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal restraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion." McCarthy was obsessed with "The Red Menace", and was willing to abandon just about any ethical or legal constraint to both cleanse the United States, and to spread his idea of Americanism. He enlisted industry, traditional elites, and whatever political support he could find his obsessive pursuit of cleansing the US of communism (and homosexuality). What's especially scary is that you write off his wholesale destruction of careers and lives as an ethically justified approach to the problems of the Cold War (and his problems with homosexuality), despite the tactics baring a striking similarity to the CCCP's enforcement of party politics through social, commercial, and direct governmental intimidation. We're lucky that McCarthy was never truly unleashed on the Red Menace; your implied support of him and his tactics is abhorrent.
- smsm42 13y agoMcCarthy did not abandon "just about any legal constraint", it is plainly untrue. There were no mass imprisonments of suspected communists without trial, no summary executions, no concentration camps for suspected communists - nothing of the sort that communists were actually implemented for years. Instead, people were called into legal proceedings - in which they could also have counsel if they wanted - and were asked if they were communists. And if they didn't want to answer that - they took the Fifth. >>> He enlisted industry, traditional elites, and whatever political support he could find Unlike any politician with the cause, which never ever uses industry, elites and other political support. I didn't know we are practically surrounded with fascists - our whole government is composed of fascists, almost everybody relies to support of the industry, elites and political groups affiliated with their causes! You opened my eyes! >>> What's especially scary is that you write off his wholesale destruction of careers I do not "write off" anything. I explain that if the person is a voluntary member of a totalitarian organisation headed by a violent dictator Joseph Stalin, organisation which murdered millions in its home country, drowned multiple countries in blood and caused uncountable deaths and suffering all over the globe, and currently is actively engaged in both hot and covert war with the US - I can understand if some people do not want to entrust sensitive positions to the judgement of such people. Either these people are not of the sound mind, or their personal goals are not aligned, mildly speaking, with something that the rest of Americans would want to happen. If you think not wishing to associate with such people is morally reprehensible, you may want to seek friendship with some KKK or White Pride or Westboro Baptist Church members, but my ethics says these are not the people I'd like to be anywhere near them. >>> despite the tactics baring a striking similarity to the CCCP's enforcement of party politics Surely, that's exactly how it happened in the USSR - if somebody was found working for foreign organisation bent on overthrowing communists, he was asked nicely if it is true, and after he refused to answer the worst could happen to him was losing his job, after which he would either just find another one or live off public assistance. This system is exactly what is widely known as GULAG. True story, bro.
- einhverfr 13y agoYou might find it interesting to hear from a lawyer who helped pioneer these tactics in the Canwell hearings in Washington State (who happened to be a relative of mine): http://depts.washington.edu/labhist/cpproject/caughlan_interview.shtml http://depts.washington.edu/labhist/cpproject/caughlan_inter... By the time HUAC came around, actually, the reasons to take the fifth were quite well developed. Additionally he had helped someone come up with a strategy of refusing to answer questions without an appointed attorney present which had the effect of getting a lot of lawyers who weren't even necessarily civil libertarians thrust into the front lines. The result was that Canwell lost re-election. This was before HUAC even got formed. You have a point about McCarthy but only from a different direction. McCarthy was an exponent of what was going on. He did not turn America into anything. He was just the final wave. We do have McCarthy to thank however for the great free speech protections we enjoy in our nation. It was due to his overreaches that the court ruled that spreading the Communist ideology was protected under the 1st Amendment unless one actually went so far as to try to raise an army to violently rebel (the case was Yates v. United States). The great irony was that whatever McCarthy's lust for power or his intentions, he succeeded in showing the court why Communists had to have civil liberties too and perhaps turned the US into something better, very much despite his best efforts.
- smsm42 13y ago>>> You might find it interesting to hear from a lawyer who helped pioneer these tactics in the Canwell hearings in Washington State Looks like this person made a career on defending the worst of the worst. The article - which is no wonder - tries to paint it in ligher tones by saying communists and BPP were "prosecuted for radical beliefs" - but we all know it went way, way beyond mere beliefs there. Still, of course, maintaining legal representation even to the worst of the worst is the important part of the due process, so I guess he has a place in the picture too. Though I'm not sure if we heard about a guy who defends the right of local Al Qaeda group to hold meetings in your local civic center, we'd think "he's the hero of our time", even recognizing their right for legal representation. As for the practice of taking the Fifth, I can appreciate that people associating with organisation with official goal of overthrowing US government and which is financed and directed by Joseph Stalin would feel the need of some defensive tactics when the same government their organisation is trying to overthrow comes in and asks questions. I can also appreciate they may think it was unfair that they suffered some serious problems due to their association with the CP, but think about it - would you want a known Al Qaeda member to be in charge of the gas lines in your city, for example? Yes, he personally never did anything wrong except being publicly in support of Al Qaeda and their actions, which is not a crime, so would you be OK with him in this position or would you demand him to be replaced?