2 ms·
I think with email expectation of privacy is exactly the same. And 4th amendment, saying "papers", obviously does not mean "only something that is never recorde
by smsm42 13y ago
I think with email expectation of privacy is exactly the same. And 4th amendment, saying "papers", obviously does not mean "only something that is never recorded can be private and protected from government". Obviously papers are very permanent things.
In the same vein, then, mail should not be protected, since you give it to the postman to send, so nothing prevents them from opening the envelope, reading everything inside, copy it and tell the police. I don't see how this is any different from taking emails from private email mailbox. In both cases I expect only machines and people that need to read it for purposes of the transmission to access it, and only in parts that are necessary for such transmission to happen, and do not expect them to disclose it to anybody else.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not the fact that e-mail is recorded. It's the fact that e-mail is recorded and retained by third parties. The mail example is interesting. A letter sent via FedEx or UPS is not protected by the 4th amendment. Letters sent via the Post Office are protected, because in that case the "third party" is actually an organ of the government.
- gohrt 13y agoSo, they only place the govement can't search is...documents in its own possession?
- smsm42 13y agoBy the same logic, if you rent a storage locker, it can be searched without a warrant since it belongs to a third party. Or your rental house can be searched, since you only rent it from the third party. And if you put your bag in a taxi trunk, you just gave it to a third party, so if the police stops the cab, they can search the bag without any probably cause. How does it make sense? I don't see the logic. If you give it to the government, you can expect privacy from the government, but if you give it to somebody else, government can take it? Makes no sense. It's like saying if you confess to the police officer, he can not testify against you, but your own lawyer has to. Completely opposite of what reasonable person would expect.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI think with email expectation of privacy is exactly the same. Yours may be, but it's the Supreme Court's opinion that actually counts.