4 ms·
If you believe in sexual self-determination (that each person has the right to decide what happens to their body), then how can you say people do not choose to
by sp332 13y ago
If you believe in sexual self-determination (that each person has the right to decide what happens to their body), then how can you say people do not choose to be gay?
- mikeash 13y agoThere are really two different concepts here, that of who you're inherently attracted to, and that of who you actually try to sleep with. The latter is a choice, but evidence appears to be that the former is not. The phrase "is gay" generally refers to the former, although obviously it can be hard to determine if a person is really good at hiding it.
- sp332 13y agoBut who you're attracted to changes, sometimes quickly. And even in general, it's not like most straight guys are attracted to all women, just as a trivial example. How many women would they have to be attracted to before they're straight? If they like one guy is that enough to count as being bi or gay? I don't think it makes any sense to define "straight" or "gay" in those terms. Edit: Specifically, it makes no sense to me that people are "born" being attracted to a certain group of people.
- stdbrouw 13y agoFacts don't stop being facts because they sound weird.
- danielharan 13y agoA picky hetero woman doesn't magically become gay. If you're equally attracted to men and women but only have sexual relations with members of one group, you are bi. There certainly is a continuum from straight to gay. Plenty of people have tried to "cure" gays, including some unhappy with their own orientation. These efforts are failing, suggesting where we are born on this continuum is not in our control to change. If you feel like you are able to change your orientation, it may be that you fall closer to the middle of the spectrum than most. Do you believe it was a choice or your environment that most shaped your orientation?
- sp332 13y agoI think the concept of orientation is so simplistic that it is useless in any practical situation. The people that I am attracted to are women. That doesn't mean I am attracted to all women. It also doesn't mean that I would want to (or choose to) have sex with any particular woman, even ones I'm attracted to at any given time. It especially doesn't mean that a person's body is the only determinant in whether I am attracted to them!
- chipsy 13y agoThe asexual community has put a great deal of thought into how to define various kinds of attraction. For a starting place: http://www.asexuality.org/wiki/index.php?title=Lexicon http://www.asexuality.org/wiki/index.php?title=Lexicon
- jules 13y agoI don't understand what's the trouble here. You say "the people that I am attracted to are women". Hence, assuming you are a male, you are heterosexual. Nothing about being a heterosexual male implies that you are attracted to all women, and nothing about being a homosexual male implies that you are attracted to all males, and nothing about being a bisexual male implies that you are attracted to all males and females. Now it's certainly the case that these three words do not describe everything completely, since for instance you can have a bisexual person who is mostly attracted to females and occasionally attracted to males. That doesn't mean that the terms are useless. The terms 'alive' and 'dead' have the same problem: there is a grey area between them. Doesn't mean that those concepts are useless.
- sp332 13y agoOK, pretty much with you so far. Now I'm trying to show that the choice of whom to have sex with is not at all the same thing as the non-choice of whom to be attracted to. Even gay people have the choice not to have sex with people of the same gender, exactly the same way straight people have the choice not to have sex with people of the opposite gender.
- tommorris 13y agoI didn't choose to be gay. I did choose to wear a blue shirt today, and buy an Android smartphone. None of them are good reasons to treat me differently in the workplace or under the law. Nothing about the unreasonableness of such discrimination changes if being gay were a choice.
- lholden 13y agoThere is a difference between being gay and having a gay relationship. You can choose to have a relationship... but nobody chooses to be gay. "Gee, you know... I think I will choose to be something that a large portion of the world hates, thinks is somehow wrong, or think is disgusting. That sounds like fun!" It's not like being gay is some fad that one decides would be cool one day while idling at the pool.
- SimHacker 13y agoBecause there is a world of difference between "being gay" and "acting on being gay". The homophobic self loathing repressed closet cases always try to define "gay" as "acting on being gay" so that they can rationalize their feelings that they have to work so hard to repress. The actual definition of "being gay" revolves around having those feelings, not acting on them. Otherwise there would be no such thing as a gay virgin, or a straight virgin for that matter. If "being gay" or "being straight" had to do with behavior, not feelings, then you couldn't be straight without first having had straight sex.
- sp332 13y agoIf being gay is about feeling, how can anyone say that a person is born gay? You're not born with feelings, are you?
- SimHacker 13y agoYou've got to be joking, right? Please tell me you don't have kids. Please.
- sp332 13y agoPeople are attracted to specific other people at specific times in a variety of ways. I can see how it's useful to define terms for certain categories or patterns of feelings. But why would we expect people to immutably belong to one of these categories of convenience?