3 ms·
How so "not really a loophole"? Congress had the opportunity with the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 to authorize the NSA to conduct dragnet operations to identif
by btilly 13y ago
How so "not really a loophole"?
Congress had the opportunity with the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 to authorize the NSA to conduct dragnet operations to identify US citizens of interest. They very explicitly did not do so, and identified that as the line that the NSA was not to cross.
The scenario that I outline has them getting around the issue by having UK analysts conduct that dragnet operation, and then coming back with a list of US citizens that the NSA should look into. Those citizens would then be targeted by a national security letter or by a FISA court warrant.
This would effectively be a dragnet operation of the kind considered and explicitly rejected by Congress as being permissible, being justified under the reasoning, "Well, we weren't the ones who did it!" Yes, I know that as a lawyer your idea of a loophole is different than mine, but in my eyes, and the eyes of most Americans, that's a loophole.
Now is it happening? My honest suspicion is that it is, for the simple reason that it is hard to filter these data streams, and the raw is more useful. Thus unless they have specific cause to do otherwise, the UK gets broad access. If that happens, then every other part of my scenario fits within the interests of those involves, and so is certainly happening. The UK will follow data trails, and if they lead to US citizens will notify the US. The US, upon hearing such notification, will certainly act on the tips.
Assuming that it is happening, what will the response be? My sense is that the national security consensus from both parties in the USA would basically wind up saying, "You shouldn't have done that, here is a law making sure you won't get into trouble for having done that, now please protect us and try not to get in the news based on how you do it."
Based on past interactions I would bet that you're OK with that consensus position. As will not surprise you, I'm not OK with it.