3 ms·
"Separation of powers" is such a bogus concept. We've got three groups of people in different office buildings with almost exactly the same set of incentives, a
by baddox 13y ago
"Separation of powers" is such a bogus concept. We've got three groups of people in different office buildings with almost exactly the same set of incentives, and it's hammered into our heads that this somehow will cause government to police itself. I doubt anyone who didn't repeatedly hear the praises for separation of powers in school throughout their childhood would think that is even a remotely effective plan.
- justncase80 13y agoAnd the superior alternative is what?
- jlgreco 13y agoThe phrase "Democracy is terrible, but it is the best we've got" makes some sense. But "American Democracy is terrible, but it is the best we've got"? That's a new one to me.
- ace_of_spades 13y agoTransparency and the possibility for the people to review at least high level policy.
- baddox 13y agoSociety refusing to tolerate any group of people having a legal monopoly on the use of violence.
- mgarfias 13y agoThis please.
- betterunix 13y agoSeparation of powers is a good concept. The problem right now is that all three branches of government have been taken over by the right wing; there is little disagreement about these things. Separation of powers tends to work best when there is more than one opinion.
- bmelton 13y agoAre you suggesting that the executive branch has been taken over by the right wing?
- betterunix 13y agoDoes that suggestion surprise you? You are talking about an executive branch that is putting tanks, helicopters, and other surplus military equipment in the hands of local law enforcement. For decades, the executive branch has encouraged the use of plea bargains to avoid having cases go to trial. The soldiers who enforce our laws have been deployed against researchers who published the wrong books. Spies have been sent into peaceful anti-war groups. How would you describe the government that undertakes such actions, and then tries to amass even more power?
- sillysaurus 13y agoThe soldiers who enforce our laws have been deployed against researchers who published the wrong books. What? Spies have been sent into peaceful anti-war groups. That's been going on ever since the time of Martin Luther King Jr, and maybe before then.
- nitrogen 13y agoWhat? Probably in reference to the labs of an author of a well-known pair of oddly titled chemistry books being raided.
- bmelton 13y agoEven with these recent scandals, I find it somewhat difficult to categorize Obama's policies as right wing, but I was just seeking clarification.
- cmdkeen 13y agoClassifying such things as right wing is part of the problem. "Left wing" governments are just as capable of all sorts of statist, authoritarian activity. But saying it is right wing annoys right wing people who are liberal, saying it is left wing annoys left wing folk. Politics is more than a left right axis.
- elwin 13y agoSeparation of powers was designed to prevent a few bad actors from seizing control of the whole system, as frequently happened in ancient republics. It's actually worked well for that purpose. It wasn't intended to defend against incentives affecting everyone who gets into any kind of office. No one foresaw that weakness. People keep talking about separation of powers because it was once a good solution to a problem that no longer exists.