6 ms·
It's not that he's factually incorrect, it's that his conclusions are insane and that's what makes him dangerous. Like Glenn Beck, he starts in the realm of rea
by astrodust 13y ago
It's not that he's factually incorrect, it's that his conclusions are insane and that's what makes him dangerous. Like Glenn Beck, he starts in the realm of reasonable and ends up painting a picture that's surreal.
His solution to these problems is to disconnect, to remove himself from the equation to the best of his ability. No cellular phone. No internet connection. No credit cards. Cash only. Don't use web services. Turn off cookies and JavaScript and Java. His answer to any problem seems to be to boycott it, as if that'll change things. Who but Stallman can operate like this? Not even secret agents are as paranoid, they're trained to hide in plain sight.
What someone in his position should be doing is talking about how to avoid this dystopian future by promoting standards, accountability, and more transparency. They should be engaging with law enforcement to understand their need for information and protect a person's right to privacy. There's a legal framework out there that needs updating by people that understand technology, but if they're all stubbornly opposed to co-operating, more stupidly out of touch laws will be passed.
This is why the EFF and organizations like it are extremely important. They're not advocating shutting down the internet just because it's being wiretapped. They're not hiding in a cave while invasive laws are being passed.
- throwaway420 13y agoI object to you calling his conclusion insane. While his response to this (almost completely removing himself from society) is unrealistic for the majority of people, his conclusions here are not insane, and are frighteningly accurate and prescient. I actually disagree with Stallman on a lot of political issues, but highlighting the dangers to liberty in the wake of attacks is completely sane. The only thing about Stallman that I find insane is his personal grooming habits/food choices.
- ninjac0der 13y ago"Who but Stallman can operate like this?" I think the real question is why people pretend they cannot and end up acting helpless. My co-workers can't even say no to $startup that acts like it's a requirement that you put your picture and bio on the company website. Some will grunt and complain about it, then act like I did something wrong when refusing this request (which is never presented as a request, of course). People are the problem here, the government is doing exactly what I would expect when you have a bunch of ineffectual serfs running around.
- Androsynth 13y agoexactly. A better question would be "How can we operate like this?"
- pyre 13y agoThe government already has information on who you work for (via taxes), so putting up a picture and a short bio (e.g. "i like long walks on the beach") isn't going to change much.
- nknighthb 13y agoGreat, so we've gone from "Someone other than you knows, so why shouldn't the government?" to "The government knows, so why shouldn't everyone else?".
- ninjac0der 13y agoIgnore the crypto approach for a minute. The issue is responsibility. If we aren't responsible directly for the crimes our government commits, who is. People look at the scale of the problem, the difficulty of the solution, and decide because it's too difficult, it's not worth doing. Why? Because they haven't really accepted responsibly. Our government is invading other nations on false pretense... what have you or I done in return? Shouldn't the wheels screech to a halt at this point? Why didn't they? Because no one is responsible to inact a solution we actually believe in, because all of the solutions require too much damn work. There was a comment below to the effect of "If only terrorist targeted the real problem instead of innocent civilians...", I don't think the comment was meant as sarcastic, which just depresses me further. You don't plant a tree underneath a power line then blame the tree for doing what's expected, known, and in their nature. #edit, I shall elaborate as I know I sound crazy. Think about software, the employees complain for more time to refactor, the boss continues driving forward with feature creep and reactionary programming/patching/hotfixing. The developers are just as responsible for the quality for the software and will have to support the decisions. Instead of putting their job on the line to stop this behavior before it's too late, they grunt, complain, and meet their silly deadlines. Fast forward a few years, the company cannot keep talented developers, simple new features take years, now the developers are ready to either quit or put their foot down, but now it's way too late, bad choices in data partitioning, scheme design, etc, now you need a complete rewrite. See how the solution scales with the problem? To me, the problem is out of hand, so naturally people will start trying to start doing what should have been done a long time ago, except it's too late, and the actual solution is still met with "well, no, but I'll do the easier version now".
- Zigurd 13y ago> it's that his conclusions are insane Until the early 80's there was no widespread use of mobile telephony and internet. It's not crazy to think that the surveillance state has ruined the internet and that there is more value in avoiding it than in using it. Maybe it's over. I can recall some TI managers looking at Stallman like he had two heads when he told them, over 25 years ago, that developers would make money with free and open software. The car industry is facing a generation of buyer who find cars a burden. It's crazy to think that we can't screw this up.
- SkyMarshal 13y ago>His answer to any problem seems to be to boycott it, as if that'll change things. False dicotomy, he's done more than just that. >What someone in his position should be doing is talking about how to avoid this dystopian future by promoting standards, accountability, and more transparency. Or, hacking the legal system to create an entire class of intellectual product resistant to the kinds of control he criticizes? Plenty talk, Stallman is one of the few who has done. Honestly, what more could be expected of one person.
- astrodust 13y agoStallman and the Free Software Foundation may have started this movement, but they haven't been the primary driver for the last decade. First it was Linux, then a multitude of others like RedHat and Debian that built on the Linux foundation. Now there's a robust ecosystem built on and around open-source. Where before The Free Software Foundation and the GPL were important at pushing things forward, they are now holding things back. People want even more freedom than the GPL offers, they'd rather use the MIT or BSD license. In some circles, GPL is the kiss of death, that no matter how good the software is you can't use it. My point is Stallman has done important things, but if he thinks he's still as singularly important as he once was, he's delusional. The movement is much, much bigger than one person taking a stand against proprietary printer software. It's millions of people working together to make software as a whole better. Nobody will ever be at the center of this movement again. If Stallman moved to a tiny island in the Pacific and was never heard from again we'd get by, and many of us wouldn't even notice. He's done his part and left his mark. By way of contrast, when we lose someone like Aaron Schwarz we're diminished. He was someone who was not just opinionated, but motivated to change things. He didn't just write papers or give speeches, he wrote software to further his cause, he went out of his way to challenge the status-quo and force people to to pay attention. We desperately need more people like him.
- dTal 13y agoI'm not sure how that's "by contrast". How exactly does "He didn't just write papers or give speeches, he wrote software to further his cause, he went out of his way to challenge the status-quo and force people to to pay attention" not also apply to Stallman? Stallman probably wrote even more code than Aaron Swartz, in addition to writing the first software license that guaranteed the freedom of all future users of the software. All licenses, including proprietary ones, are shunned by some people; the effectiveness of the GPL is evident in the simple fact that it's the most common free software license in use today by a wide margin. So what if Stallman doesn't contribute to software projects much anymore? The whole point of this link was to direct attention, not to his coding skill, but his unusual foresight, which he retains.
- tedks 13y agoThose aren't Stallman's conclusions; they're his immediate actions. His conclusion, at the bottom of the page, is: > Please let your elected representatives, and your unelected president, know that you don't want your civil liberties to become the terrorists' next victim. Don't wait -- the bills are already being written. Refusing to be surveilled in the meantime is a temporary measure that Stallman adopts because of his extreme deontological ethics. He does that in the background, to the extent that it doesn't interfere with his work for a large non-profit dedicated to political activism. Remember, he used a computer with non-free software on it until the Lemote Yeeloong was released.
- leephillips 13y agoYour points would probably be better received if you did not exaggerate. He of course does have an internet connection, as he uses email. Plenty of people turn off some subset of cookies, javascript, and java (who has java turned on?). I agree that better subversion comes through acting normal and engaging people closer to their own terms.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jleader 13y ago"better subversion comes through acting normal and engaging people closer to their own terms." But the "better subversives" need someone to point to, to say "you think what I'm suggesting is unreasonable and difficult? What about this guy's suggestions?" It's called shifting the Overton window; the people who do it generally aren't widely liked (or likable), but if we all stayed closer to the center, we wouldn't get nearly as much movement as we'd like.
- astrodust 13y agoMaybe he's more flexible now, but I'd read that he browses the web by downloading pages over email, and even when it came to email it was under very strict self-imposed rules. Honestly, he sounds like he's never given up on UUCP.
- icebraining 13y agoWell, he posts on his website every day commenting on articles from other websites, so whatever solution he uses, it seems it's effective enough.
- lolcraft 13y agoYou haven't read him. Those aren't his conclusions. Those are his personal actions, as a single person without any political power. If you're a judge in an international human rights court, you bring Coca-Cola forth to respond to their hire of murderers. If you're just a bloke of the street, you might boycott Coca-Cola, if only just for having a clear conscience. What his conclusions actually are have been stated many times before. Free software in every device, under the GPL. Free software in servers, under the AGPL. Being able to install open source firmware on those devices. Using free standards. Banning intrusive DRM, restrictions to second hand sale, et c. All very reasonable and implementable today, if there were the political will. Well, maybe not all very reasonable, but reasonable to varying degrees. Still, I don't get why you are so worried about Stallman, when he actually wants what you want.
- dllthomas 13y ago"His answer to any problem seems to be to boycott it, as if that'll change things." If you're an engineer with a penchant for scratching your itches, boycotting problems does change things.
- 8934089 13y agoThis post is inaccurate about how Mr. Stallman uses the internet, among other things. See: stallman.org/rms-lifestyle.html stallman.org/stallman-computing.html