6 ms·
Ignore Y Combinator at Your Own Risk
- chaosmachine 18y agoAmusingly, the first comment on the story is by some guy confused by the author's use of the word "hacker".
- ivankirigin 18y ago"Graham clearly wants to drink some big-cap milkshakes." His own words, I'm sure.
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoThis is some solid press for YC, but I don't really understand the title...who is putting themselves at risk by ignoring YC?
- Maciek416 18y agoI think the author might be referring to the "big companies [who] are cutting back and letting talent go". There seem to be repeated suggestions that YC alumni will nibble away or topple the Fortune 500's, uh, fortunes. With a lot of these startups creating new markets of their own I'm not sure I necessarily agree with that zero-sumesque view, but I wouldn't be surprised if they cause some interesting disruptions.
- quizbiz 18y agoI don't think I would call the Motley Fool "solid press". Maybe that's just me. Not to say YC doesn't get or doesn't deserve great press coverage.
- irrelative 18y agoYou know you've made the big leagues when people write fluff pieces like this about you. Congrats guys!
- danhak 18y agoNot a fluff piece so much as a layman's introduction to YC.
- landist 18y agoCouple of thoughts: 1. Maybe a bit fluffy, but since most mainstream readers don't know about Y Combinator, the first cycle of articles are going to trend positive. 2. I think the Y Combinator ecosystem (the program, demo days, Hacker News) itself is going to prove as disruptive (if not more) as the companies they fund. A disruptive "Ivy League of Startup Schools" is starting to form that I believe will have huge ripple effects on our economy. 3. I agree, mainstream media doesn't understand how much hackers are our era's Robber Barons (or Industrial Statesmen, take your pick). Expect a handful of IPO's and at least one billionaire graduate within the next ten years. I expect Y Combinator graduates and their related companies will have billions of dollars of impact on our economy over this period of time. 4. The traditional University model of education is probably as much at risk by ignoring YC as is big Fortune 500 companies. "The average debt for graduating college seniors who borrow to finance their undergraduate degree is just under $20,000." vs. the avg. YC funded company probably gets funded to the order of $15k - $20k. "In 2003, workers with bachelor's degrees earned a median of $49,900. Those who'd completed several years of college with no degree had median earnings of $35,700, while those with a high school diploma averaged $30,800." Don't get me wrong, I understand that not every high school graduate can attend YC or some similar program. But I think our educational system needs to create some alternative tracks for education that are shorter in time frame, more entrepreneurial in nature, and more technically inclined. If we simply diverted 1% of college freshman into such programs, this would translated into over 20,000 individuals. Can you imagine the impact on society of 20k freshman attending some Y Combinator-esque hacker / entrepreneurial program every year? http://money.cnn.com/2005/10/17/pf/college/college_costs/index.htm http://money.cnn.com/2005/10/17/pf/college/college_costs/ind...
- SwellJoe 18y agoCan you imagine the impact on society of 20k freshman attending some Y Combinator-esque hacker / entrepreneurial program every year? I don't think YC could, or would want to, replace college. The average age of founders that get into YC has increased slowly but steadily...it's now about 25, so folks have been out of school for maybe three years, on average. pg has said on more than one occasion that he likes founders who know what they're avoiding (corporate drudgery, primarily) by starting a company, and he's found they're better able to hold the line when things suck (which they always do to some degree during the first few months to a couple of years of a startup). That said, I think high school kids who show an interest should be given access to resources along the lines of YC. A fellow from Tulane ran an entrepreneurship program at a high school in New Orleans a year or so ago, I think as some sort of project for school, and he raised money via a ChipIn to bring the best of the lot out to Silicon Valley to see it all in action. Several YC companies volunteered to sit down with them for a few hours and talk about the process, and make it seem human and do-able for ordinary non-genius type folks. He also lined up visits to Google and Facebook and a few other valley highlights. I'd be stunned if that didn't have a positive impact on at least a few of those kids (underprivileged kids from poor neighborhoods in this case, but I think it'd work for most kids). Maybe one or two of them have businesses of their own today. So, I think that kind of thing would be great for the economy and great for the kids...but it's not something you could do as an investment company. It would take funding that you don't expect to get back, either donated (perhaps by companies) or grants from the government, and involvement by schools. It's just not something that is going to produce a profitable portfolio...but it could certainly put the kids on the right track.