4 ms·
Here's the thing - all this and they've announced ZERO arrests. Whatever the heck they are doing, they are spending a fortune, eroding everyone's privacy forev
by ck2 13y ago
Here's the thing - all this and they've announced ZERO arrests.
Whatever the heck they are doing, they are spending a fortune, eroding everyone's privacy forever, and accomplishing nothing.
Can't wait for a few years when they get hacked and a foreign government steals all the data. Of course we will never know because whomever leaks that it happened will end up in gitmo or be Bradley Manning'd.
This country has lost its freaking mind since 9/11
- gboudrias 13y agoYour (and my) government was never sane, 9/11 was just very good for propaganda.
- mtgx 13y agoNot to mention that I'm pretty sure they've been doing stuff like this for many years back since 9/11. It wasn't just this event. They are now saying that they're doing this to protect US against other Boston bombing type incidents and such, but clearly all the surveillance they've done so far hasn't helped that either. So I think the boston bombing is a convenient excuse to become bolder with every such incident, and ignore the Constitution even more.
- nikcub 13y agoThe zero arrests could be because they are reluctant to reveal that NSA domestic data collection is being used as a source in indictments. The NSA could simply throw up leads which are then investigated by the FBI who would collect evidence to be used in indictments using more traditional means. This would also mean that the legality of NSA data collection isn't tested in courts as submitted evidence. I'd be surprised to learn that they are collecting all this data and aren't finding crimes to investigate and arrest people over. I can imagine that the NSA send all sorts of tips to the FBI to follow up on, but that only the follow up part ever ends up in court filings or as evidence.
- forgotAgain 13y agoWhat would be real interesting to know is if they find out about any crimes committed by the politicians with responsibility for oversight of the NSA and what they do with that information.
- will_brown 13y agoThey did...Elliot Spitzer was the Governor NY, as you may recall he resigned when it was revealed, in 2008, he was involved in a prostitution scandal (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eliot_Spitzer_prostitution_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eliot_Spitzer_prostitution_scan...). Of course the federal warrant-less wiretaps contained so much information it was revealed the Honorable Spitzer's affinity for lady's of the night spanned his reign as Attorney General and Governor (at least 2004 - 2008), just to give an idea of the expansive record they are building on everyone.
- ajross 13y agoNot to argue with the core of your point, but the "arrests" bit is missing the point. The NSA mission isn't law enforcement. Their job is purely to better inform executive decisions. And from that perspective they're equally successful if they prevent a terrorist event (or more broadly any harm national security) via putting someone in jail, killing them with a drone, blackmailing them, or just snitching on them to their family such that they're forced to give up their plan. It's not inappropriate to view this as a huge overreach. But neither is it correct to treat them like the FBI.
- darkarmani 13y ago> Not to argue with the core of your point, but the "arrests" bit is missing the point. The NSA mission isn't law enforcement. Exactly, right. They should be banned from operating inside the US by the Posse Comitatus Act and by their founding act The National Security Act of 1947. Why are we so eager to turn them into the KGB?
- anigbrowl 13y agoPosse Comitatus Act Dubious.
- brown9-2 13y agoI think this is a misassumption of what the military's Cyber Command does. It's not about arresting domestic criminals, but countering attacks (or perpetuating attacks) from other nation-states on our infrastructure.
- darkarmani 13y ago> I think this is a misassumption of what the military's Cyber Command does You mean what they say it does.
- anigbrowl 13y agoHere's the thing - all this and they've announced ZERO arrests. Arrests for what? This information gathering is entirely legal. As I've pointed out elsewhere on HN, your telephone records (not the content of your calls) have been an open book to the government since 1979, by order of the Supreme Court. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_v._Maryland http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith_v._Maryland I appreciate (and partly agree) that you feel this sort of large-scale data harvesting should be illegal, but it isn't.