4 ms·
IQ tests are pretty sophisticated and, as the theory of intelligence or more correctly intelligences has evolved, the tests have evolved alongside. Each test i
by jacques_chester 13y ago
IQ tests are pretty sophisticated and, as the theory of intelligence or more correctly intelligences has evolved, the tests have evolved alongside.
Each test is really a suite of dozens of subtests, each of which tries to tease out some aspect of mental function. Some of it is pattern matching. Some of it is memorise-and-recall. Some of it is tests of "general knowledge". And on and on. Think of what you consider to be a distinct kind of mental performance and somebody, somewhere, has built a test for it.
I think it's important to distinguish between three things in discussions of IQ:
1. Are some people "more" intelligent than others?
Taking the fuzziest, least precise view of what "more intelligent" or "less intelligent" means, I think yes. It would be very strange that the architecture of the brain and environmental factors would lead to perfectly equal outcomes in all subjects. And it doesn't seem to fit what we can casually observe around us.
2. What is intelligence, and what are the components of intelligence?
A very large body of research discusses, explores, argues and delves into these simple questions. In general a single "IQ" figure is merely a statistical index of the subtests. The sub-category indices are much more revealing.
3. Can the tests actually accurately sample these components?
Also hotly contested. The closest we can come is to compare the test scores statistically to other outcomes, or to other tests. IQ tests which correlate highly with life achievement (factoring out stuff like socioeconomic background, sex, race and mental health) are preferred over those that don't. You can argue that it's circular, and you'd be right.
Welcome to psychometrics, where there is no outside world available for objective instrumentation.
- einhverfr 13y ago> Taking the fuzziest, least precise view of what "more intelligent" or "less intelligent" means, I think yes. No argument there. > In general a single "IQ" figure is merely a statistical index of the subtests. Which is why I point out that any weighing between subtests are relatively problematic in generating that number. > The sub-category indices are much more revealing. 100% agreed there. > The closest we can come is to compare the test scores statistically to other outcomes, or to other tests. But the problem is, the ability to accurately sample these components may not be the same for each component. For example, if you want to measure coordination of multiple pieces of information short term memory, the problems are very different than if looking at pattern recognition. So I would caution against a single answer. However if we don't understand which subtests are particularly problematic and what the epistemological problems look for each subtest, then many of the really interesting questions about these tests (for example why do Asians score higher than whites) are forever out of reach. > Welcome to psychometrics, where there is no outside world available for objective instrumentation. Yep.