4 ms·
"You Are Probably Not Much Smarter or Dumber Than Anybody Else" I've noticed that people seem to be completely unable to really understand that some people are
by ars 13y ago
"You Are Probably Not Much Smarter or Dumber Than Anybody Else"
I've noticed that people seem to be completely unable to really understand that some people are actually smarter than them. Most commonly they will confuse aptitude for intelligence. i.e. they easily acknowledge that this person just likes intellectual activity. But can't seem to grasp the difference in intelligence.
The same [relative] lack of intelligence also robs people of the ability to understand intelligence in others.
It's easy to see when someone is less intelligent - it's much harder to really grasp that someone people are smarter. It's like trying to explain a red to a colorblind person who can't see red. They kinda get that it's another color like others they've seen before, but they just can't grasp that it really exists.
You also (less commonly) get the reverse - someone really smart doesn't understand why everyone can't do it.
An example: Srinivasa Ramanujan heard the number 1729 and instantly thought of an interesting property for it. This ability to do that for a number just doesn't exist in most people. It doesn't matter how hard they try or study - they just can't do that.
- fnayr 13y ago1*7+2=9
- yaakov34 13y agoThat's not a property of the number 1729, that's only a property of the decimal notation for the number; an important distinction. The property is also trivial. Ramanujan's property - that the number is expressible in two different ways as a sum of two cubes, and in fact the smallest number so expressible - is a property of the number. That Ramanujan had different innate abilities from the vast majority of people is about as clear as the midday sun.
- einhverfr 13y agoThere are two problems though with this view. As a disclaimer, there are people who I consider much smarter than I am at certain things, and many people regard me the same way. Some of that may be my attention deficit and the effort I have had to put in to being successful despite it. I think the problem though is different, however. I am going to say two things: 1. Intelligence is not definable to the point where it can be tested, and 2. Attitude > innate intelligence. I expect both these will not be so welcome in the HN community as such, so I am prepared for downvotes, but I also dont think these are wrong either. On the first, the fact is that people process information differently. Ramanujan processes a number a certain way. Someone else might associate it with a year and immediately make historical connections. Someone else may factor get fascinated and factor it. There are bunches of ways a piece of information can be processed and the weighing of one as better than another is ultimately a cultural judgement and ultimately what proves to be an interesting property depends on what we find fascinating (which brings me to my second point). On the second, I have found all my life that the smartest people I have known have always been the most humble, and to regard everyone else as being worthy of learning from. I have consequently come to regard intelligence as a two-fold habit. The first part is the habit of finding everything interesting in life, what I call an unwillingness to be bored (something that really comes through in Feynman's memoires). The second is regarding everyone as someone to learn from (Heisenberg btw comes across this way very much in "Physics and Philosophy"). If you go around learning from everyone, and refuse to be bored, you will quite quickly become smarter than everyone else if they refuse to do the same.
- Nursie 13y ago>> 2. Attitude > innate intelligence. What do you mean by greater than? Attitude like you describe is only really open to people above a certain level of intelligence. If you just don't get mathematics, language etc etc because of inbuilt limitations (yes, some people have these) then you're not going to get that far.
- einhverfr 13y agoWhat I mean is that most of intelligence intelligence is a habit cultivated by attitude rather than limited by an inborn capacity. This doesn't mean there isn't a basic shape given by innate aspects (at least for some people), but that most of what we'd call intelligence is developed rather than inborn.
- Nursie 13y agoI would be interested to see any research you have seen that points in that direction. I think that people are more restricted by hardware capabilities than you like to imagine. That said, I asked what you meant by 'greater than' because I don't believe that raw intelligence always translates to success at life, whatever that may mean.
- einhverfr 13y agoWell, at some point software affects hardware though regarding our brain. Could Sapir or Chomsky have been great linguists if they only had one native language and learned the other languages at, say, the age of 10?
- Nursie 13y agoThat's true, there is definitely environmental feedback involved. However people can grow up in the same environment, with the same access to learning, and have very different outcomes.
- auctiontheory 13y agoGoogle: Dunning-Kruger Effect
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]