3 ms·
Does anyone here really believe that IQ tests have any value?
by arethuza 13y ago
Does anyone here really believe that IQ tests have any value?
- queensnake 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#Social_outcomes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_quotient#Social_ou...
- hackinthebochs 13y agoI do. It is correlated with all kinds of positive outcomes in life. Given a somewhat similar cultural upbringing, there is clearly something different about someone with a 140 IQ vs someone with a 100 IQ. This fashionable meme that IQ is meaningless has no basis in fact. It certainly doesn't measure innate potential exactly, but then not too many people would say that these days anyways. However, it does correlate with something regarding one's mental capacity, and this correlation also correlates with other important outcomes.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoIt is correlated with all kinds of positive outcomes in life. I beg to differ, and I have this quote to rationalize it: "Pain and suffering are always inevitable for a large intelligence and a deep heart. The really great men must, I think, have great sadness on earth." -- Fyodor Dostoevsky Would I rather be stupid and happy? No! And maybe I'm not of "large intelligence" in the first place, but I'm intelligent enough to often feel very disconnected and alienated from the society around me. I learned how to tell people what they want to hear, but inside I often feel like I'm trapped in some kind of zoo. The heat death of the universe is the only grown up thing I actually get to deal with, and I get to deal with it alone, while most everybody else is either drunk on brain chemistry or not playing in that league. I feel like I'm sitting in some kind of waiting room where there is nothing to do. If it wasn't for things like music, dancing, cats, dogs and toddlers, there is no way I would have made it this far. Flowers and sparrows nourish me, people are a chore. Capitalism? Don't even get me started, unless you're willing to give me an army with which to solve the issue. And now I'm going to completely contradict myself and say that intelligence is like the horse power of an engine; yeah, it matters, you cannot go anywhere without an engine, and you can't go fast or far with a crappy one. BUT what might matter even more is the steering wheel, and I totally suck at using that. I speed around a lot and end up in ditches, and I think there is something to the "saying" that more intelligence makes bigger mistakes possible; I am a living example of that. I know I am just whining. My personal inability to enjoy life and other people doesn't have to mean intelligence isn't generally positive; but still, when it comes to society and living and working together, it's all rather relative, and being too smart or too stupid both can easily lead to inefficiencies and heartache. Humanity as a whole might have better outcomes if it was more intelligent as a whole, but individuals being too far ahead cannot do much other than acknowledge all the beautiful things that could and should be but never will. That said, I would never ever want to swap. I'm sure less intelligent people have things they are sad about as well, while being worse equipped to reflect on them, and I do not envy that at all.
- grey-area 13y agoI've never liked the idea of IQ tests, but they do correlate quite well with future achievement like jobs, income, incarceration rate etc. That is why they are still used: http://www.iq-tests.eu/iq-test-Practical-validity-800.html http://www.iq-tests.eu/iq-test-Practical-validity-800.html
- arethuza 13y agoI'm in the UK and I've never encountered IQ tests as part of education or any work environment. [NB For my own amusement I did sit a test as a teenager and got a stupidly high score, which I can actually explain pretty easily, that rather demonstrated how shallow the tests seemed to me] I've also never directly encountered anyone discussing their IQ - which would strike me as very silly indeed.
- iopq 13y agoIt's probably illegal to give IQ tests to potential employees. It is illegal in the States.
- einhverfr 13y agoUnder what theory? Disparate racial impact? Before I get downvotes for that it is worth noting that racial groups do have remarkably different IQ test results in the US. Whether that says anything about intelligence or genetics is hotly debated in some circles. It isn't clear how much is cultural, whether there are subtle cognitive differences between racial groups, and even of so whether this corresponds to any intelligence difference.
- jlgreco 13y agoIn the US, IQ tests are (in some states) used in public schools during part of a process to identify students who have unique potential that may be realized if special consideration, privileges, and opportunities are given to them. So called "gifted" programs. For example, I used one of these programs to spend half my highschool career playing Doom on school computers, and spend the other half of my highschool career taking courses at the local branch of the state university.... Yeah, not a perfect system. Using IQ tests during hiring is legally risky in the US because it puts you at a high risk of discrimination lawsuits. Subsequently, where you see them in the US, they are masquerading as something else (think "puzzle"/"outside the box thinking" interview questions for programmers).
- scotty79 13y agoIQ correlates nicely with the amount of lead child was exposed to while growing up and the probability such grown up child will be involved in some kind of petty crime activity later on. Such measure must have some value.