4 ms·
China Faces a Grad Glut After Boom at Colleges
- potatolicious 18y agoThis phenomenon is not unique to China. At the University of Waterloo here in Canada, we've been building out "hot majors" exactly as the article describes: hot-button buzzword-of-the-year degree programs that attract hopeful students and then kick them into the pit of unemployability. Case in point: the new nanotechnology program, which has a dismal employment rate, and most of the employed students are cannibalizing existing chemical engineering jobs. And it continues this year with the introduction of "management engineering", a concept that is still ill-defined and nebulous, and seems more like a grab at tuition dollars than a genuine academic affair. Disclaimer: I am in neither of these programs, I'm just sick of this university and its profiteering ways, and how it has been run like a private business as of late. Maybe we should try expanding the campus instead of selling out our government-granted land to build a new office park (oh hey, the article covered that too), or trying to out-buzzword ourselves by building a campus in Dubai. Ugh. This sort of academic gross mismanagement is global.
- biohacker42 18y agoA lot of countries, most of then developing countries, see the connection between prosperity and a lot of advanced degrees and think correlation = causation. It's a lot easier to send bright kids to school, then it is to fix the corruption and mismanagement that's keeping your country underdeveloped. Canada might just be overenthusiastic ;)
- ovi256 18y agoI got a "Page Unavailable" from the original URL [1]. On a hunch, I removed the "?mod=googlenews_wsj" part, and lo and behold, it worked. Is WSJ blocking GoogleNews links ? Or is this something much more mundane ? 1. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124087181303261033.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
- DougBTX 18y agoWFM, much more mundane I expect.
- gaius 18y agoMr. Zhang got his degree from a school of traditional Chinese medicine with no history of teaching computer sciences. China, like Dubai, is going to learn the hard way that you can't compress centuries of development into years, or even decades.
- indiejade 18y agoUniversity was once akin to "finding one's place in the Universe." Yet it seems like the more the pursuit of profit overlaps the goal of furthering humanity, the more difficult it becomes for people who want to further humanity (science, engineering, etc.) to do so.
- gaius 18y agoI don't know about that, the college I went to to get a degree in Mech Eng had strong ties to industry and did lots of useful research. Most of the professors had consulting gigs on the side; the chap that taught us Thermodynamics & Turbomachinery was doing real jet engine design, the chap that taught us about control systems was also working on real systems for North Sea oil rigs. It's only in the humanities and so-called soft sciences that academia's disappeared up its own backside.
- megaduck 18y agoBingo. I think it's widely unappreciated (even in China) that China's entire educational system is only thirty years old. During Mao's rule, all the schools were shut down while teachers and intellectuals were denounced, sent to labor camps, imprisoned, and killed. When they started up again in 1978, they were effectively starting from nothing. It's frakkin' hard to bootstrap an educational system, especially for over a billion people. It takes educated people to produce educated people, and there just aren't enough educated teachers to go around. The situation is slowly getting better, but it's certainly not improving fast enough to stamp out millions of high quality graduates. The problem is compounded by Chinese pedagogy, which has a "Moses down from the mountain" flavor to it. If your teacher gives you bad or incomplete information, then you're stuck with that. Both critical thinking and autodidactic learning are almost entirely unknown. The Chinese government should be given credit for recognizing the importance of education, but I think this time their reach has really exceeded their grasp. China is going to have to scale back its expectations, and that process will be shockingly painful.