3 ms·
I was intrigued by their mention of this "Jim Stickley" who was cited as a top security expert. I had never heard of him before, so did a quick search to find
by mindcrime 13y ago
I was intrigued by their mention of this "Jim Stickley" who was cited as a top security expert. I had never heard of him before, so did a quick search to find out a little more about him. He seems to be a pretty legit and well known security guy[1], but it surprises me that he said:
This is really frustrating because clearly they've figured out something that looks really simple and whatever it is they're doing, it takes just seconds to do," Stickley said. "And you look and you go, 'That should not be possible.
Considering, again, that there has been published research on this topic, and a presentation at Black Hat, revealing that (at least some) cars are vulnerable.
Honestly, I feel like the reporter on this article should have done a bit more background research and interviewed a few more people. Not that it changes the fundamental issue (don't leave valuables in your car, etc.) but it would have been a stronger article with some more context, IMO.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Stickley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Stickley
- droopybuns 13y agoI agree with your skepticism but I disagree with your analysis of Stickley. This looks like the typical security clown out there writing his own wikipedia entry. His article's main point seems to be that he found a buffer overflow. There, he's a security expert. What security professional worth his salt says "that should not be possible"? The entire security profession is about identifying assumptions and then challenging them. He sounds more like a software developer cashing in on the "s" word because he found a buffer overrun than a security profesional assessing an attack.
- mindcrime 13y agoYou're right, actually. I was trying to be charitable though, and I didn't feel like I had time to do a serious deep dive into this background and credentials. Nor am I necessarily qualified to pass any serious judgement on his knowledge. A quote from somebody like Bruce Schneier, or tptacek, would have been a lot better.
- darkarmani 13y agoWell we criminalized (DMCA) this kind of "hacking," so as far as this "security professional" knows it is impossible because he hasn't heard of it. Maybe if we stop preventing security researchers from talking about vulnerabilities we could know about these things before the thieves.
- narrator 13y agoThey should hire someone like Dan Boneh[1] to look for cryptoanalytic attacks. Of course, I'm sure he'll find a whole bunch of attacks. That's going to be a really expensive to repair all that faulty crypto hardware. [1]:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Boneh http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Boneh
- daeken 13y agoJim Stickley is -- being kind -- a hack. He was on the Today Show showing off my hotel lock exploit without credit, and got zero details correct. Gotta respect his ability to press-whore (I tend to think I'm fairly good, but he puts me to shame), but that's about it.