4 ms·
> Flash completely dominates CSS/HTML/JS for rendering text accurately Except that the resulting rendering is an image so you can't copy and paste. I suppose
by lisper 18y ago
> Flash completely dominates CSS/HTML/JS for rendering text accurately
Except that the resulting rendering is an image so you can't copy and paste. I suppose some content providers will consider that a feature, but as a user it seems like a serious bug to me.
- ownedthx 18y agoActually that's no problem... The SWF in the article were two snapshots that I overlayed, one from Flash, one from Word, so it has no interactivity with the curser. Truth is, it's entirely possible to enable text selection, if that were a real demo of the text engine.
- dandelany 18y agoThen you failed to get your point across... Both of the demos you show may as well be images. There's lots of other reasons not to use Flash, namely that its slow for lots of text, and it doesnt display anything at all on the iPhone and other mobile platforms. Using SIFR to replace headers is OK, but beyond that, I still hold that using Flash for text (on the web) is bad form.
- jonah 18y agoMay I ask why you chose Word as your comparison? It's not known as the paragon of typeography. :(
- jonah 18y agoEek, that'd be "typography".
- addicttostress 18y agoWhy didn't you use a live demo?
- ownedthx 18y agoJust the way it worked out. I had taken many screenshots along the way, but at the time I decided to write about my findings, I was in mid-refactor and had nothing that I could run. In hindsight, I should have used the real deal.
- sjs382 18y agosifr allows copy and paste fine. There is a problem with other browser-specific features though; the right-click options are provided by the flash app rather than the browser. (like firefox's "search in google")
- briansmith 18y agoThere are a lot of cases where sifr doesn't allow copy and paste fine. Nowadays I run into it every day when I copy blog articles into Evernote. Depending how you do the text selection and what text you actually select, it doesn't work. I will be glad when sifr is dead--hopefully it will be next year.
- sjs382 18y agothen its a problem with the developer or the fact that they're using an outdated sifr. the newest version of sifr does this fine