3 ms·
I would never join (as a founder) a team that did not have 100% vesting. People quit, unpredictably. Vesting protects founders. I'm fine with the basic idea of
by mindcrime 13y ago
I would never join (as a founder) a team that did not have 100% vesting. People quit, unpredictably. Vesting protects founders.
I'm fine with the basic idea of vesting, and you're right, it does protect the founders (from each other) to some extent. What I have an issue with, is a scenario where you work, as a founder for, say, 3 years, and then take outside investment money, and the investor demands 100% of your founder equity be subject to vesting and/or a "zero price" buyback clause. I would never, ever take that deal. A lot of things can happen, and there is value which has already been created by the 3 years that was put in.. as a founder, I'd expect to retain some percentage of my equity based on that. The exact details would, of course, have to be negotiated.
- Silhouette 13y agoA lot of things can happen, and there is value which has already been created by the 3 years that was put in.. Indeed. I'm surprised to see so many people here think that a 100% lock-in is reasonable. That effectively sets a zero value on the work done to date, while at the same time presuming that a company is established enough to be worth serious investment, which is paradoxical. I don't see how this really protects founders to a useful degree either, at least not for very long. While some degree of vesting creates an incentive for everyone to stay on board and do their best to make the project a success for everyone, it doesn't need 100% of the money involved to do that. Even if it did, there wouldn't be 100% lock-in after presumably no more than a year, and then you're back to having a significant chunk of equity that isn't locked in anyway. So again, the argument that a 100% initial lock-in and 4 year vesting period are both necessary seems to contradict the idea that you start releasing a significant fraction of the locked equity after only one year.
- tptacek 13y ago100% 4 year vesting is a day-1 requirement, but how much of vesting resets on a new round is obviously a negotiated point.