4 ms·
Thus far, I'm agreeing with you. Facts have nothing to do with the rhetoric being spewed. It's all just tribalism. As a progressive, I had believed that we cou
by specialist 13y ago
Thus far, I'm agreeing with you. Facts have nothing to do with the rhetoric being spewed. It's all just tribalism.
As a progressive, I had believed that we could all reach some kind of agreement, if only we could talk it out. Not understanding why that wasn't working, I started researching (Don't Think of an Elephant, What's Wrong with Kansas, etc) and experimenting (practicing talking points on right wing family and friends).
It's been illuminating.
One of my brothers was advocating higher effective tax rates, deficit reduction, and so forth. So I said "So you'd support returning to Clinton era policies?"
The answer surprised me.
He said no. I asked why not. After some musing, he told me Clinton era economic growth was a "false economy". Um, okay. If he had something about bubbles, I'd totally agree. But all he had was "false economy". Probably something he heard on the radio.
I've had similar discussions about healthcare. Every single value, position, complaint, etc would suggest the belligerent would support universal coverage with a single payer. But dare suggest it and there's a strong reaction. Hell no, that's socialism. Or whatever.
I've decided there's no profit in attempting persuasion.
The only successful strategy is to organize better than your opponents. The purpose of rhetoric (messaging, persuasion) is to motivate one's supporters or neutralize opposition.