4 ms·
Too bad they ended this article with such a weak quote from Sen. Leahy "Unfortunately, misuse of low-quality patents through patent trolling has tarnished t
by javajosh 13y ago
Too bad they ended this article with such a weak quote from Sen. Leahy
"Unfortunately, misuse of low-quality patents through patent trolling has tarnished the system's image."
This implies that "the system's image" is the thing he's trying to protect, rather than the livelihoods of people just trying to make a living in a free-market economy. When small businesses are sued for scanning a document and emailing it[1], there's more at stake than "the system's image".
[1]http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/01/patent-trolls-want-1000-for-using-scanners/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/01/patent-trolls-wan...
- Pxtl 13y agoThat demonstrates a problem not just with the patent system, but the legal system itself. There will always be a number of people who will cave to a legal threat if they have enough money to pay off the threat and not enough money to fight it... unless the legal threat has some sort of risk associated with the one making the threat, there will be people who take advantage of it. As horrifying as it is, I'm actually kinda happy this nasty crap is going on. The best way to get a problem fixed is to exploit it relentlessly.
- rayiner 13y agoFundamentally, the legal system is a way for individuals to invoke the state's monopoly on force to resolve disputes. That's the point. As long as there is law, there is the possibility for abuse, and that possibility is a cross-cutting concern. Now, you say that the issue is associating some sort of risk with people invoking the legal system, but that's a very tricky path to walk down. What if you think someone breached a contract with you, but a court disagrees? Does losing a case inexorably mean you were in the wrong for having brought it? I personally don't think that penalizing people for invoking the legal system is the way to go. The best solution is to make it cheap to reject meritless cases. After all, anybody could file suit claiming you trespassed on their land, and they could do so maliciously or mistakenly. We don't worry about frivolous suits for trespass because the underlying property right is clear and well-defined, so that if you do get sued it's really easy to show that you did not violate that right. The ease with which a case like that can be dismissed automatically disincentives people from bringing nuisance cases.
- snowwrestler 13y agoThe "system's image" is important because the end to all patents or IP would be absolutely devastating to the U.S. economy, killing way more jobs than patent trolls do. The public needs to trust the patent system.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoCitation needed; eliminating patents in general or software patents in particular would hurt some companies (notably patent trolls and other companies who make most of their money on patent licensing) and help others (notably those who regularly get sued by those companies, and those who spend time and money writing and filing patents and creating cross-licensing arrangements for defensive purposes). The question of which of those will have a larger impact on the economy, and for that matter which behavior we would prefer to see encouraged, remains open and does not have a well-known or accepted answer as you've implied.
- snowwrestler 13y agoIn your example, companies who get sued over patents today, would instead just see their products copied wholesale and sold for much lower prices, since the copying companies have no investment to recoup. Without the possibility of recouping investment, new product development would slow, stifling innovation across the economy. Which in turn would harm companies that exist solely to copy other products, since there would be fewer new products to copy.
- JoshTriplett 13y ago> In your example, companies who get sued over patents today, would instead just see their products copied wholesale and sold for much lower prices I think you mean "companies who sue over patents", not "companies who get sued over patents"; the latter are not the ones looking to prevent copying. I'd also point out that that issue doesn't apply to software patents, since copyright already handles that issue quite effectively for software. > Without the possibility of recouping investment, new product development would slow Standard patent rhetoric. The corresponding anti-patent rhetoric would be that without the issue of spurious patent lawsuits and workarounds, product development would accelerate. Both claims require evidence, not just assertion. > Which in turn would harm companies that exist solely to copy other products Because of course the world is divided solely into companies that love patents and companies that exist solely to copy other products. There's a large ecosystem of innovative companies that treat patents as overhead and cost rather than value.