7 ms·
Are there really people who feel like the government shouldn't enforce property rights? Aren't those just called anarchists?
by mikeyouse 13y ago
Are there really people who feel like the government shouldn't enforce property rights? Aren't those just called anarchists?
- TallGuyShort 13y agoSee my sibling post for more on my own opinion on the matter, but that all hinges on whether or not you consider IP property rights. Is the exclusive right to use an idea an inherent, basic human right, like freedom-of-religion or freedom-of-speech? Or is it a government granted monopoly?
- notahacker 13y agoAll property is a government granted monopoly in the present system, although much of it would be accepted through social convention or defensible by private force in the absence of government. Copyright/patents would probably be defensible for the sufficiently powerful too...
- TallGuyShort 13y agoOf course, the libertarian perspective is that the government's ability to grant those monopolies is granted by the people to whom that property belongs. The rights don't come from the government, the rights are just there. The government sees to it they are not infringed upon.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> See my sibling post for more on my own opinion on the matter, but that all hinges on whether or not you consider IP property rights. Is the exclusive right to use an idea an inherent, basic human right, like freedom-of-religion or freedom-of-speech? Or is it a government granted monopoly? All property rights are government-granted monopolies (including rights to real property and tangible personal property), whether or not they are also inherent, basic human rights.
- darkarmani 13y agoYou mean on real property or on gov't invented property created through government "interference" and "regulation" over free markets? I don't see how having gov't create a right around "patents" (non-tangible "property") is any different than any other gov't regulation that libertarians rail against. (Taxes? Those are just GP "government property".)
- mikeyouse 13y agoSo there is no such thing as intellectual property? If Pfizer spends $10B over two decades to develop a drug, JohnDoe Co. can recreate it on day-1 in the market and compete against Pfizer without penalty? Do people really want to live in that world?
- darkarmani 13y agoThere is no such thing as IP until created by what people in other instances would call "gov't interference." I understand the trade-offs involved and I'm not actually arguing for no IP, but more about the fact that it is held sacred, but any time the gov't does anything else that is "bad."
- dragonwriter 13y ago> You mean on real property or on gov't invented property created through government "interference" and "regulation" over free markets? By "real property" are you referring to government-created exclusive rights over land (which is what the term actually means), or are you referring to government-created exclusive rights over tangible portable assets (which is "tangible personal property" rather than "real property", but frequently mistakenly referred to as "real property" by the kind of people that criticize "imaginary property"), and, in either case, how are these government-created exclusive rights different meaningfully different than government "interference" and "regulation" over "free markets"?
- darkarmani 13y agoI meant both. Land, improvements on the land, and any affixed items and also the opposite of fake. I don't think those gov't created rights are any different than any other gov't regulation, which is why i put it in scare quotes. People worship those property rights created and enforced by the gov't, but call the same amount of "interference" in other areas as regulation.