5 ms·
Mattermark (Formerly Referly) Wants To Be The Data Signaling Platform For VCs
- sethbannon 13y agoNeat idea, though I wonder how large the market really is for selling data to VCs.
- radagaisus 13y agoThis is really big with Israeli VCs: http://www.ivc-online.com/ http://www.ivc-online.com/
- benologist 13y agoI think it'll also prove useful for companies wanting to make acquisitions or poach employees, journalists, and as sales leads when companies reach different growth stages and require new/more tools and services. The mailing list will be worth something too.
- jenntoda 13y agoVCs might not need this (yet). But I can see this selling like hotcake to the impending ballooning new group investors in the startups scene enabled by the ranks of wefunder.com, fundersclub.com, etc. Go Danielle and team!
- orangethirty 13y agoThink Hedge-funds.
- callmeed 13y agoThis was my thought exactly. Even with seed funds and angel investors, the number seems small (AngelList for example shows about 18K investor accounts). Perhaps the amount of money they have (and you can charge them) offsets this a bit.
- orangethirty 13y agodmor, I just won a $100 bet by calling this. Thank you. Anyhow, their marketing strategy has been very fun to watch and unfold. It has literally been done live on this site and most people did not get up in arms offended. Which is the smart way to do content marketing. They have also launched a business with what is simple an excel spreadsheet of data. I know they have code for it, but they could have launched with off-the-shelf software. Imagine that!
- citricsquid 13y agoSomeone took that bet?!
- orangethirty 13y agoThe bet was: Mine - refer.ly would die and a new company would arise. The new company would be about business meta data. Then as she published the blog articles, I modified to state they would be selling data to VCs. I knew the so called pivot to compete with medium was a bluff, because there was no financial incentive to do so. Plus this team had always been very data driven. The other bet - They would pivot into a medium with social features (AKA a social blogging platform(whatever that means)).
- larrys 13y ago"I knew the so called pivot to compete with medium was a bluff" Um you are wrong about that. I worked with someone who was helping them, with, let's call it branding, on that idea. So unless that was part of the elaborate ruse, they were thinking of doing the pivot.
- rdl 13y agoIt was funny having insider information under FrieNDA on exactly what she was doing (dmor and kevin are awesome SF YC founders, talked about some other startups with dmor, etc.), and seeing this bet.
- andrewhillman 13y agoData is always nice but most investors invest via gut, but this is probably more about not missing a company than finding a company.
- eclipxe 13y agoI'm adding this as another data signal for my "are we in a bubble index"
- PaybackTony 13y agoThe biggest problem here is that on average (as in, the vast majority of start-ups that never get mentioned anywhere outside their niche) a majority of successful start-ups don't generate any buzz or otherwise measurable data because they are too busy developing their product. Maybe that's what the product does, tries to gather data on start-ups that produce little in the form of buzz but a lot in the form of revenue. It doesn't appear so. Danielle helped me a couple times when I was using the Twilio API, she's a nice person. Hopefully this works out for her.
- minimax 13y agoThis seems like a good idea. There are a lot of wealthy traders in NYC, but the richest guy in the city is the one selling all the traders neatly packaged financial information.
- larrys 13y agoCorrect but keep in mind that was a different era and also that involved a hardware (bloomberg terminal) component that was a barrier to entry (in addition to the data gathering that is). Also there are many more well healed participants in that market I believe.
- tocomment 13y agoWhat happened to Referly? That seemed like a good idea.
- uncoder0 13y agoYeah. I would love to read a retrospective about refer.ly if one exists.
- zmitri 13y agoAmazon referrals are too good that there is no reason to use referly. If anyone clicks on an Amazon referral link, and ends up buying something else on the site -- not just the item you blogged about -- you still get the money and leave the hard part to what amazon is best at -- suggesting things you might like and getting people to checkout.
- rdl 13y agoWirecutter is a better execution of "product reviews" than anything I ever saw on Referly. I never wanted 15 different opinions of varying quality and unknown provenance about the 5 best headphones; I wanted one great comparison, which Wirecutter consistently is.
- rdl 13y agoThis seems really useful for everyone, not just in investors. Learning about customers/vendors is useful.
- intropic 13y agoDanielle's new blog strategy now makes a lot more sense! :)
- crapshoot101 13y agoHmm, I'm skeptical, but would definitely like to be wrong. There are a lot of people trying to be the VC data source (VentureSource, Dashboard.Io, Datafox, internal proprietary tools), but the problem is that most aren't that useful at capturing what's valuable. @PayBackTony has the right point below - the problem is that the majority of relevant data here is qualitative, and by that very nature, harder to capture. Additionally, there really aren't that many VC's out there - I assume the goal / scope is to go beyond that.
- programminggeek 13y agoWow, Referly only generated $33,883.38? All that press and effort and only 33k in commissions? That is seriously terrible. I don't know what all the fuss is/was about, but in terms of affiliate marketing money, that's not a large amount of revenue for one solo affiliate, let alone a whole company...
- orangethirty 13y agoWhy is it terrible? Sure, money was lost. But terrible it is not.
- programminggeek 13y agoI meant that it's not a lot of money, it's wasn't very successful for the amount of time/effort/marketing/press it got. It was all over TC and other publications. One would assume that would correlate to more success, but I guess that would be a false assumption.
- orangethirty 13y ago"Press" coverage does not a success make. It does, however, buy a lot of cheap VC money for later investments. One thing to learn from this is that media coverage won't do much for you if the business model is skewed. Still, there is always Cherry.
- dsugarman 13y agonot very many startup business models work from day 1. Startups are interesting if they are growing, not necessarily a foolproof business model; you are consistently patching the holes. If you get a lot of press coverage, it probably means you are a good hustler and marketer, which is pretty vital to your success. If the market is bad, switch markets. Kudos to Danielle & Kevin.
- rdl 13y agoBigger thing was the opportunity cost for the team; that team probably was worth $50-100k/mo to be working on something else. Which is why they pivoted.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- imjk 13y agoNot to sidetrack too much, but was there ever a postmortem on Referly? I thought it was a great idea, and the Referly homepage currently only shows stats that ostensibly show strong usage. I still think a user-curated affiliate referral platform has a lot of potential. My only criticism of Referly was that it was too overtly publicized as a platform for publisher to make money versus platform to display your curation talents (a la Pinterest, Tumblr, and even other blogging platforms), a subtle but important distinction. I think a platform built with curation in mind first, and then a secondary means to make commissions would do well.
- thesash 13y agoThere are two actually: http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/03/zombie-startups/ http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/03/zombie-startups/ and http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/04/double-tap/ http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/04/double-tap/
- SparksZilla 13y agoActually one more as well: http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/03/numbers-in-action/ http://www.daniellemorrill.com/2013/03/numbers-in-action/
- tomasien 13y agoSo that's what all those blogs were about! Remarkably similar to what Paul is doing with Dashboard.io except he's been doing it for a while. Not that that's a big negative, I think it's good when smart people are seeing similar opportunities at the same time. Best of luck!
- photorized 13y agoIt's a neat concept. However, with any product or service that's so narrowly defined - wouldn't you be concerned about your markets size? There are only around 500 active VC firms in the US... How much would they pay for the intelligence?
- codex 13y agoIntriguing and promising idea. I think the most interesting market here is angels; the bigger firms already get a good look at the most promising deals. If the execution proves successful, Mattermark should become accredited investor and ask for a small number of shares per deal in each VC (or angel's) fund in lieu of a subscription fee.