5 ms·
He could make a much bigger difference if he simply saved a large portion of his earnings over his career, invested them (if he's working for a hedge fund he sh
by Mikeb85 13y ago
He could make a much bigger difference if he simply saved a large portion of his earnings over his career, invested them (if he's working for a hedge fund he should be able to get a great return), and then invested that much larger chunk into 3rd world entrepreneurs/businesses.
The unfortunate truth is that most money that goes into charities that operate in 3rd world countries gets spent on logistics, bureaucracy, and gets siphoned off by corrupt governments or stolen by thieves. He'll save someone from malaria one day, and they'll die from another cause later.
A much bigger impact would be to invest in those 3rd world countries (conscientiously), and provide jobs and livelihoods for those people. Build infrastructure, enable access to capital, machinery and technology, security, etc... That will make a much larger difference than any amount of money poured into charities and feel-good causes.
- LeeHunter 13y ago"The unfortunate truth is that most money that goes into charities that operate in 3rd world countries gets spent on logistics, bureaucracy, and gets siphoned off by corrupt governments or stolen by thieves. He'll save someone from malaria one day, and they'll die from another cause later." Self-serving selfish unsupported claptrap. I especially like the line "He'll save someone from malaria one day, and they'll die from another cause later." Hard to argue with that point since we'll all die from some cause later. As if, for example, funding the inexpensive operations to relieve the suffering of women with untreated obstetric fistulas (http://www.fistulafoundation.org/whatisfistula/faqs.html http://www.fistulafoundation.org/whatisfistula/faqs.html) is just a waste of time and money. Sheesh.
- Mikeb85 13y agoHow much time do you spend in 3rd world countries? My wife is from one, we spend a month a year over there... They were a recipient of the one laptop per child initiative - most of the laptops were stolen and placed on the black market. Corruption runs so deep that most foreign aid has been withdrawn, and foreign corporations refuse to use local labour in local construction initiatives. Giving away mosquito nets is a great initiative. Producing the sort of infrastructure that allows people to buy them with their own money is better. The Chinese have done more for the 3rd world (any my wife's country) than every Western charity and government combined. You go to my wife's country - all the local infrastructure is built by Chinese corporations, and most of the cost is donated by the Chinese government. What little debt remains to China is forgiven periodically (China just wrote-off 355 million in debt to this country). If you eliminated corruption, it would be even more effective, these Chinese corporations would be more willing to use local labour... By the way, even the link you provided cites poverty and malnutrition as the main cause of fistula. Do you want to treat diseases or prevent them as well as raise the economic status of those in need?
- LeeHunter 13y agoAnecdotes are not data.
- Mikeb85 13y agoNo, they're not. Alot of data is flawed though, based on assumptions that usually aren't true... Go on the ground yourself and see what makes a difference though. You can't sit on your computer in a 1st world country and think you know what happens in the 3rd world...
- LeeHunter 13y agoI spent a year living in a third world country but somehow it failed to make me an expert on international aid and development.
- dnautics 13y agothat's actually incorrect. The correct quote is "the plural of anecdote is data". http://blog.revolutionanalytics.com/2011/04/the-plural-of-anecdote-is-data-after-all.html http://blog.revolutionanalytics.com/2011/04/the-plural-of-an... I take the opposite view of this statistician, because it reminds us that NO data are free of some level of collection bias. Keep in mind I'm an experimentalist, and not a data analyst.
- justin66 13y ago> The Chinese have done more for the 3rd world (any my wife's country) than every Western charity and government combined. You go to my wife's country A quick perusal of the link below and some of the associated material shows how what you're saying here regarding the wonderfulness and light coming from China is ridiculous: http://www.cfr.org/china/expanding-china-africa-oil-ties/p9557 http://www.cfr.org/china/expanding-china-africa-oil-ties/p95... > What little debt remains to China is forgiven periodically (China just wrote-off 355 million in debt to this country). Ah, yes, debt forgiveness. Always a sign that benevolent and highly effective foreign intervention is in progress.
- davorak 13y ago> The unfortunate truth is that most money that goes into charities that operate in 3rd world countries gets spent on logistics, bureaucracy, and gets siphoned off by corrupt governments or stolen by thieves. My understanding is that he was using givewell.org to help make his discussions along with the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation founded research into the effectiveness of mosquito nets. Both of which provide some solid evidence of the effectiveness and long term impact. > A much bigger impact would be to invest in those 3rd world countries (conscientiously), and provide jobs and livelihoods for those people. This has to be weighed against the compounding returns that can be received from the money being used sooner. For example the mosquito nets save some lives help stabilize a village and allow them to invest more time in improving another aspect of their life. Usually to have this type of impact their is a critical amount of money that has to be invested at once. I do not know where that critical level is, it could as low as tens of thousands of dollars going through the right charity something that the discussed individual does yearly.
- bvk 13y agoIn principle, I agree with you. Charities should be valued for their practical benefits and the return they get on their donations rather than the sentimental value they provide their donors. But the article Brooks is responding to makes note of the fact that the man making these donations did significant research about what charity he should give to and found that the most cost-effective way to reduce human suffering was to save lives by donating to a charity that gives away mosquito nets. He is explicitly eschewing the feel-good nature in charity in favor of the utilitarian viewpoint that human suffering should be reduced in the most efficient possible way. The cost, taking into account all the details you mention, is $2500 per life saved. I don't think it's obvious that $2500 invested in a business does more to reduce human suffering than $2500 in mosquito nets. After all, business, which is always an investment, is more attractive when there is less fear of an early death by malaria.
- Mikeb85 13y ago2500 per life saved? The math doesn't add up. A mosquito net will sell on the street for around $10 (USD or CAD) in a 3rd world country (like where my wife is from - we bought a new one when we were in town - I got bit many times) - and that's with a good chunk of the profit going to the street vendor. That means 250 mosquito nets for $2500. So either mosquito nets prevent malaria for only 1 in 250 people, or a majority of that $2500 is going to waste. And believe me, I'm not against foreign aid - but stimulating local economies, empowering farmers and local merchants, and even just travelling and spending money is more effective most of the time.
- gohrt 13y agoPeople who have actually studied the issue have run the numbers, and the math does add up: Short version: http://www.againstmalaria.com/WhyNets.aspx http://www.againstmalaria.com/WhyNets.aspx "Each net costs about $3 [prices dropped recentl], lasts for 3-4 years, and protects, on average, two people." The statistics are well known given the scale of the problem. Every 50-250 nets we put over heads and beds, one child doesn't die. http://www.givewell.org/international/top-charities/AMF#Costperlifesaved http://www.givewell.org/international/top-charities/AMF#Cost... http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/insecticide-treated-nets/macro-evidence http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/ins... > So either mosquito nets prevent malaria for only 1 in 250 people, or a majority of that $2500 is going to waste. Malaria is not always fatal, malaria is not the only threat to life, and malaria is a persistent threat -- to life a life free of malaria requires about 15 nets, each with a lifespan of about 3-5 years.