7 ms·
Imagine you honestly believe in intelligent design. You probably know most people believe the opposite, so when you encounter poll designed by people you don't
by ajuc 13y ago
Imagine you honestly believe in intelligent design. You probably know most people believe the opposite, so when you encounter poll designed by people you don't know you assume they believe evolution theory is true, so if you want to win money you say whatever it takes, no matter what you believe.
So IMHO this experiment measured how well people predict what experimenter thinks is correct, and not how people beliefs change when incentivized.
To control for this divide the group that gets money into 2, and say to one subgroup you're republican think-tank, and to the other you're democrat think-tank, and compare the results :)
- jbooth 13y agoIn your metaphorical question, there is actually a correct, factual answer and it's not intelligent design.
- DennisP 13y agoI'm guessing ajuc agrees with you, but it's completely beside his point.
- ajuc 13y agoYes.
- jbooth 13y agoI'd say that admitting something is generally accepted as true (which you're agreeing the respondents did) is the first step towards admitting that it might actually be true. The truth isn't subjective, and it seems that the survey elicited that from people to an extent.
- samatman 13y agoThis is certainly a factor that needs to be controlled for. To me, the most interesting part of the study is that, by rewarding correct answers and confessions of ignorance, they got the most accurate results. I would like to see that effect studied for its statistical significance, and for the technique to be applied to polling if it proves to in fact increase the accuracy of the signal.
- samatman 13y agoSomething like 'This survey asks questions about facts and opinions. Your compensation depends on correct answers to factual questions. Answering "I don't know" to a factual question is worth N% of a correct answer.'
- jessriedel 13y agoThis is an additional complicating factor, but it's not some fundamental problem with these type of studies. There are facts that essentially all people agree to be true when provided with all the information ("objective facts"), and the question is how people's subjective beliefs about these facts are correlated with political party when these people do not have ready access to all the information (as we usually do not).
- btilly 13y agoImagine you honestly believe in intelligent design. You probably know most people believe the opposite, so when you encounter poll designed by people you don't know you assume they believe evolution theory is true... That's a poor example that demonstrates your own ignorance about the USA as a whole. In the USA more people believe in creationism (God created everything 6000 years ago) than intelligent design. And far more people believe in intelligent design than evolution. See http://www.gallup.com/poll/155003/hold-creationist-view-human-origins.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/155003/hold-creationist-view-huma... for the numbers. It is worth noting that belief in evolution is within a factor of two of belief that Obama is a Muslim (about 20%) and belief that Elvis is still alive (around 7%).
- ajuc 13y agoYep, I assumed I encounter representative portion of USA on internet, apparently I was very wrong. USA I am disappointed. Maybe thinking global warming is a scam would be better example. EDIT: on the other hand I never stated the poll takes place in USA :)
- btilly 13y agoMaybe thinking global warming is a scam would be better example. Better, yes. Good? Depending on how you ask the question, between 2/3 and 3/4 of Americans believe in global warming. However that figure drops to under half of Republicans. (Lest you think I'm merely insulting Republicans here, let me point out that most Democrats do not understand what economics 101 says about the effects of rent control. Both parties show a lot of ignorance about the world, merely different parts of it.)
- mmanfrin 13y agoYou are missing the forest for his tree example. He was using creationism as a means to illustrate a point: that the responders probably tilted their responses towards what they thought the researchers believed instead of what they themselves believed.
- 13y ago