4 ms·
If the president has taken such a dim view of patent-holding firms, maybe he should focus on the PTO first who is giving out incorrect patents left and right. O
by belorn 13y ago
If the president has taken such a dim view of patent-holding firms, maybe he should focus on the PTO first who is giving out incorrect patents left and right. Only one in ten patents, or 12% to be exact[1], are given out in compliance with patent law.
Imagine if a bank teller had a 88% error rate when giving out loans, thus handing out large sums of money to people who can't repay it. No bank in history would allow such personal to still be employed, or they would go out of businesses thanks to competition in the market. The PTO do not have any competition, so instead we are left dealing with the after effect with 9/10 patents being incorrectly issued for fully 20 years periods. Patent trolls and patent-holding firms would likely not exist, or would at least have extremely smaller effect on the market if PTO actually did their job correctly.
[1]In an effort to assert the quality of patent, one can look at the result from reexaminations. Like with code, if it is not tested, its quality is indeterminable. The PTO publish yearly a report for ex parte reexaminations, and during the latest period of 2011/09/30 -> 2012/09/30, the reexamination certificates only gave 12% of all examined patents a pass with all claims intact. This is averaged across all technical fields, as PTO do not have numbers for specific markets. I would guess that software patents will have slightly higher number of faulty patents (~95% of incorrect patents?), but statistics over the IT industry patents doesn't seem to exist.
- protomyth 13y agoThis is fairly typical of government. Looking at how the government actually does its work is "bad". Passing a law to punish people in the courts or do some tax foolishness is considered ok. In this case, you are exactly right, looking at the input to the system and how it is dealt with there would be a better approach, but it goes against form. Both sides do this a lot. Look at the whole focus of health care costs. No debate on why they are high and how to fix the inputs. The patent troll debate is further hampered by reporters using the term willy-nilly instead of focusing on companies that actually have that business model.
- DerekL 13y agoSo 88% of reexamined patents are modified or invalidated. But how does this lead to the conclusion that 88% of all patents would be modified or invalidated if they were reexamined? An ex parte reexamination requires a fee. People don't randomly choose patents for reexamination, they only challenge the weakest ones.
- belorn 13y ago> So 88% of reexamined patents are modified or invalidated. But how does this lead to the conclusion that 88% of all patents would be modified or invalidated if they were reexamined? Untested patents is of undetermined quality similar to untested code. How do we know that untested code has bugs if most people don't write tests randomly? Well, because developer experience would argue that untested code is not a haven of bugfree or high quality software. Rather, code is seen as non-working until testing has proven otherwise. Why should we treat untested patents differently? > People don't randomly choose patents for reexamination, they only challenge the weakest ones. Got a source for that? Normally, people spend money on reexamination when other people try to extract money from licensing agreements. When companies tries to extract money from licensing agreements, don't they tend to use their strongest patents as the stick? In that sense, people don't randomly choose patents for reexamination, they only challenge the strongest ones which is the ones used in patent litigation and patent licensing agreements. But I don't have a source for that, so I guess the argument goes to the person with a source.