3 ms·
serious question - is there a reason why computer models of thought and 'weak AI' focus on biologically-inspired models instead of generalizing to higher-level
by dnautics 13y ago
serious question - is there a reason why computer models of thought and 'weak AI' focus on biologically-inspired models instead of generalizing to higher-level cognitive phenomena? It seems like this is quite a bit like trying to model the hydrodynamics of a river flowing by going down to the quantum mechanical properties of water and dirt.
- IanCal 13y agoTo use your analogy, because starting with "WATER FLOWS DOWNHILL" and trying to work out how much energy a dam in the river could generate leads to flooded villages. 1) Modelling the higher level phenomena is really, really hard to do at anything other than a basic level. We could just build formal logic systems, but we don't want to have to put all the information in there ourselves, so they've got to learn it somehow. 2) You've got to get the concepts into the AI to start with, we're still trying to work out how to tell the difference between objects in images. 3) It is being done, it just doesn't sound as sexy and so you don't hear as much in mainstream news. 4) It may have fewer short term benefits. 5) Biology has a working example we can try and steal.
- daivd 13y agoIt has turned out to be quite hard to implement higher-level cognitive phenomena directly, so they decrease level until they find one they can implement and then try to get emergent properties from there.
- mietek 13y agoThis has been tried without success. You may have heard about the AI winter, or the failure of the symbolic approach, in the 1980s. Check out "On Intelligence". It talks about their reasons for following biological constraints, in opposition to your point of view, common among computer scientists.