2 ms·
One of the difficulties of fixing the problem is going to be that you can't just pass a law that says poof "you must be the company that makes a thing in order
by bane 13y ago
One of the difficulties of fixing the problem is going to be that you can't just pass a law that says poof "you must be the company that makes a thing in order to have a patent on a thing". There are many legitimate reasons for patents to be tradeable assets. Take for example the basement tinkerer who comes up with and patents a completely novel widget. They may not have the resources to build, market and sell that widget. But a Samsung might want to buy that patent for a couple million and make those widgets themselves.
Sure the basement tinkerer could license the patent to Samsung, even an exclusive perpetual license, which is almost as good as owning it, and might be the preferred path forward (though there can be some problems with that too as companies start to defensively buy exclusive perpetual licenses with no intention of making those widgets just to keep others out of that market).
But at this point, any law requiring such licenses would have to be for those going forward. Any retroactive law would require either handing back legally purchased patents (which destroys wealth) or require the originator to buy them back (which may be impossible in many cases if they've already spent the money on retirement homes).
The core reason patents become so valuable is because they last so damn long. If they didn't last until the next ice age it would take much of the value out of ownership and make licensing naturally make more sense anyway. The way to attack this is at the root and revert back the patent expiration to something far more reasonable.