4 ms·
I read it, but apart from the excellent beginning I'm not sure it's well worth it. The author wants to have it both ways: he's an insider and also an ironic cri
by gruseom 18y ago
I read it, but apart from the excellent beginning I'm not sure it's well worth it. The author wants to have it both ways: he's an insider and also an ironic critic. But he never addresses his own years of involvement in the bullshit he exposes. As a result, the article becomes increasingly evasive and self-justifying, ending in a bunch of platitudes of his own.
You can't just take a bucket of irony varnish and slather it over everything and act like that makes you different.
- dasil003 18y agoWhere did he claim he was different? Is it wrong for someone to criticize an industry they were a part of? Is the appearance of hypocrisy the foremost evil to be avoided at all costs?
- gruseom 18y agoWhere did he claim he was different? The whole point of the article is that his philosophy degree made him different. (Note that the sibling comment to yours takes this for granted.) Is it wrong for someone to criticize an industry they were a part of? No, but it's shallow not to address the incongruence. Is the appearance of hypocrisy the foremost evil to be avoided at all costs? One of them! Plus it makes for better writing.
- frossie 18y agoThe point that he is making is not that management consulting is useless, but the framework for teaching is ineffective. As he says, "What they don’t seem to teach you in business school is that “the five forces” and “the seven Cs” and every other generic framework for problem solving are heuristics: they can lead you to solutions, but they cannot make you think." The problem (and I see this in technical management as well as in the business world) is that a good manager can think themselves out of the situation without gimmicks or formal training; whereas a bad manager does not become a good one with all the MBAs and training courses in the world. The other great point he makes, that confirms my own impression, is: "If it’s reminiscent of the kind of toothless wisdom offered in self-help literature, that’s because management theory is mostly a subgenre of self-help. Which isn’t to say it’s completely useless." I think that is exactly right. Yes there are some people that will derive some benefit from reading a self-help book, but it rarely provides a lasting benefit and is no substitute for an intelligent and mature reflection on your problems.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]