3 ms·
Obama pledges 3 percent of GDP for research
- Femur 18y agoGDP in the US in 2008 was 14.62 trillion. 3% of that is $438.6 billion. From TFA: >To encourage private sector investment in research, Obama said he wants to make the federal government's research and experimentation tax credit permanent. I love the idea of making it more tax friendly for business who wish to conduct research. I hate the idea of the government taxing people and then dolling out that money to whomever they deem most "worthy."
- Retric 18y agoI love the idea of making it more tax friendly for business who wish to conduct research. I hate the idea of the government taxing people and then dolling out that money to whomever they deem most "worthy." That's the same thing as a targeted tax break. If the government gives you money because you do X then I pay more taxes. If you pay less taxes because you do X then I still pay more taxes.
- Femur 18y ago>If you pay less taxes because you do X then I still pay more taxes. That is not necessarily true (although it practice i recognize that it is true). Theoretically (and in my opinion optimally) the government could give the tax break Y because you do X and then continue running with (Revenue - Y) = (Budget - Y)
- Retric 18y agoIf it can run with less money then it can lower everyone's taxes.
- ams6110 18y agoYou don't necessarily pay more taxes. If a tax break motivates you to do X, and as a result you generate enough additional taxable income to offset the tax break, then the treasury comes out ahead.
- Radix 18y agoNo it's not. With option one businesses choose where they intend to conduct research. With option two the government chooses what research should be funded. It becomes something that can be politicized. But thanks for pointing out the needed general increase in tax. EDIT: Thank you for disagreeing with me, but I would like to learn why I am wrong. Would someone tell me why my observation is wrong?
- Retric 18y agoPolitically there is a difference, numerically there is not. While handing out money for people to research whatever they want would be a non starter, people are happy to have the tax code do the same thing. Granted, procedurally when handing out money the government likes to say what you do with it, but manipulating the tax code is seen as more reasonable even thought the costs are identical. My point is if we are going to be handing out money through targeted tax breaks we should still treat it as spending tax payers money, because that's the net effect is.
- natrius 18y agoThere is a great deal of basic scientific research that is not immediately profitable, but is still "worthy" of doing. Such research requires an non-profit-seeking entity to fund it. In an ideal libertarian paradise, individuals who choose to fund unprofitable research could band together and select projects, but if the government stops funding research tomorrow, what makes you think individuals are going to pick up the slack? How much unprofitable research is funded by private individuals today? Public goods merit public funding.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- rms 18y ago>Side note: do we have to discuss every vaguely technology related news bit about Obama here? This is not an inconsequential item, committing 3% of GDP to basic research may be one of the most fundamentally positive policy decisions ever made in the USA.
- gills 18y agoThe not-so-positive corollary is that 3% of GDP must be extracted from the economy before it can be 'committed' to the politically-viable science projects.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoSpending money should never be a goal in itself
- prospero 18y agoMoney is the most concrete way to quantify the level of commitment that's being discussed. Anything less would just be a bunch of hand-waving about science being super important and stuff.
- jacoblyles 18y agoOn the other hand, you have to discount the results a bit for the inefficiencies of bureaucracy and democratic decision making. For example, the billions spent on subsidizing research on the hydrogen power car undoubtedly diverted a lot of effort and commitment towards a technology that was never particularly viable. It was, however, a sexy technology to talk about on the campaign stump.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- jacoblyles 18y agoA few paragraphs down from Eisenhower's warning about the "military-industrial complex", we get this warning about the "scientific-technological elite": >"Today, the solitary inventor, tinkering in his shop, has been overshadowed by task forces of scientists in laboratories and testing fields. In the same fashion, the free university, historically the fountainhead of free ideas and scientific discovery, has experienced a revolution in the conduct of research. Partly because of the huge costs involved, a government contract becomes virtually a substitute for intellectual curiosity. For every old blackboard there are now hundreds of new electronic computers. The prospect of domination of the nation's scholars by Federal employment, project allocations, and the power of money is ever present -- and is gravely to be regarded. >Yet, in holding scientific research and discovery in respect, as we should, we must also be alert to the equal and opposite danger that public policy could itself become the captive of a scientific-technological elite." Also: I get tired of seeing every vaguely technology-oriented Obama article here. There are plenty of places on the web to discuss them. What's the limit on the number of tech advisors he can appoint?
- bokonist 18y agoBefore anyone gets too excited over this proposal, you might want to consider how government funding for science in the year 2009 works in practice. Here is an except from a blog post that describes how the Energy department works from the inside ( source: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-introduction-to-unqualified_22.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-... ): ------------------------------- Basically, my mother got involved with this world by accident. More or less everyone else in Efficiency and Renewable Energy was there because they were true believers. My mother was there because her kids had gone to college, and she needed a job. So she wound up as a budget and policy analyst, working for the true believers. This drove my mother up the wall. She is basically an honest person. She does not have the skill sets to work effectively as a member of a criminal organization, and she certainly did not expect the United States Department of Energy to be anything of the sort. Yes: that's exactly what I said. Joe Romm should be in prison. James Hansen should be in prison. Michael Mann should be in prison (and not for making Heat). These people are criminals. Sadly, no one will be arresting any of them any time soon. What my mother found at EERE was a sort of giant, Potomac-shaped hog-trough, dispensing a billion or two a year to grunting Beltway bandits packed shoulder-to-shoulder around a vast open sewer of hot, juicy, delicious cash. This is, of course, the iron triangle of Washington fame. (I think the triangle should include at the very least the press, making it a square, which would let us add Andrew Revkin to our fantasy arrest list. All you coup plotters out there, listen up. These guys are all buddies - you can probably nab all four at the same Super Bowl party.) In order to keep said open sewer open, EERE planners (such as my mother) had to go through the following process: they had to analyze a constant flow of scientific and engineering information from the renewable-energy researchers they supported (typically experienced recipients of such grants, which is why they call them "Beltway bandits"), decide which technologies seemed promising and which did not, support the former and cut the latter. Now: my mother was at DOE in the mid-90s. How many successful renewable-energy technologies can you name that came out of DOE in the mid-90s? Or came out of anywhere in the mid-90s? Or came out of anywhere at all? What are the successes of renewable energy? For that matter, even today, how many press releases have you seen reprinted in your newspaper of choice, promising that renewable-energy technology X - algae biofuel, perhaps, or Stirling engines, or thin-film solar-panels; the list is endless - would hit the market a year from now, two years from now, five years from now? For how many years have you been seeing these types of announcements? How many renewable-energy technologies have hit said market? The reason, of course, is that most of these technologies simply don't work. At least, not in the sense of being even remotely cost-effective. Of course, one can still tinker with them, and one never knows how tinkering will turn out. But what would happen at EERE, over and over again, is that some research program would promise result X by year Y, fail, add 1 to Y, and get more money for next year. My mother's job was not to evaluate renewable-energy technologies. It was to pretend to evaluate renewable-energy technologies - creating the essential illusion of science-driven public policy. Since everyone involved in this process understood that it was a farce, you can imagine the quality of the data. Meanwhile, as usual in Washington, how much money you got depended on how many friends in the right places you had. This tends not to change from year to year, resulting in remarkably consistent budget allocations. In other words, my mother's work was bullshit in the best Frankfurtian sense. Some might get a kick out of this, but she is just not the type. And at the time, Artificial Global Warming was not the big thing it is now. So the open sewer seemed picayune. A billion here, a billion there. It sounds big to the hoi-polloi, but of course it isn't. What was not obvious in the late '90s is that, if you can steal billions, you can steal trillions. And that is a big deal. --------------------------------------
- cookiecaper 18y agoI find it detestable that the government can just spend 3 percent of the GDP at its fancy. Talk about a runaway system. We've turned our government into a group of thugs and given them free reign.
- jibiki 18y agoYou misread the article. > the president said his goal can only be achieved through a combination of government spending and contributions from the private sector. The U.S. currently spends about 2.6 percent of GDP on research and development, according to the most recent National Science Board figures, placing it second overall among the G7 countries, just behind Japan. When it says "the U.S. currently spends", the meaning is not, to my knowledge, "the U.S. government currently spends".
- gills 18y agoThis is a brilliant and cheap political win for Obama. Consider the economic black hole our government (including the past administration) is leading us down; he can leave alone (or even reduce) the number of dollars spent on research and still claim an increase by percentage of GDP.