4 ms·
> Self driving cars have to handle a lot of external stimulus, like other cars, You say that, but you still have obstacles to avoid (trees, tall buildings and
by laumars 13y ago
> Self driving cars have to handle a lot of external stimulus, like other cars,
You say that, but you still have obstacles to avoid (trees, tall buildings and hills), "driving" conditions to contend with (high winds) and other "vehicles" (birds, other drones of such a scheme takes off).
> ...road regulations and thrust/steering balances on the road.
Thrust and steering is a great deal harder when you don't have a solid contact (ie movement in air vs wheels on a road). If these drones were to ever be a commercial tool, then they would be bound by regulations as well.
Plus with helicopters you have additional complications that aren't an issue with self driving cars: three dimensions to worry about rather than just two (as you don't need to worry about altitude if your a car), regional air space limitations (eg are you near an air port?) and the obvious issue of somehow notifying the customer that the drone is outside their front door (assuming the AI is smart enough to determine what bit of the house is the front door).
And to make matters worse, each drone would only be capable of one drop off at a time as you have space constraints and trust issues (you couldn't trust customers not to steal other peoples food so you'd need some kind of method to secure other customers food). Where as this wouldn't be a problem with a human delivery boy nor even an automated delivery car.
But that all said, I wouldn't say that these things are more complicated either. I think they're both equally complicated but for different reasons.
> This helicopter is quite free to move and can be "easily" tracked by gps or such.
Cars can also be tracked by GPS. That's how self-driving cars work and what's used in SatNavs. Autonomous tracking is the easy bit as that's been available in consumer technology for the best part of a decade already.
- Zarathust 13y agoTrees and buildings are static environment and can be mapped. I don't see how bird traffic can compete with road traffic, this comparison don't hold much to me. The third dimension is only an issue at takeoff and at landing which are by far the greatest show stoppers here. With maybe economic feasibility. Cars also have road navigation to handle with ugly stuff such as dynamic roadblocks and obsolete maps, all of which don't really apply to flying. Maybe in a mid/long-term future we'll see regulations for drones but it is very close to free for all as it stands right now