4 ms·
Amazing what controlling the means of production can do for you.
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
Amazing what controlling the means of production can do for you.
- mindcrime 13y agoAmazing what controlling the means of production can do for you. Well, if others want to control the means of production, let them go out and take out loans, burn through their life savings, and crib money from friends, family and fools, to take a chance on a business that might or might not succeed, possibly leaving them broke, penniless and destitute. Let them figure out how to promote and market the business, design all the processes needed to make the business work, and develop the ulcers and headaches that come from stressing over the possibility that the business might fail and you might have to lay off your entire workforce, putting good people... people that you hired, trained, trusted, and worked, sweated, laughed and bled alongside.. out of work. Because "owning the means of production" IS a total cakewalk after all. Just retreat to your robber baron mansion, burn a few thousand dollar bills for heat, and march down to the (store|factory|plant|refinery|etc) every few days and kick the shit out of the lazy workers who are probably stealing from the company anyway. Oh, wait, did I say "march"? I mean, "be driven by your chauffeur in your Rolls Royce Silver Ghost". Because all business owners have chauffeurs and a Rolls Royce.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoTo my knowledge, limited though it be, actual entrepreneurship is neither as cushy as you imply that I implied, nor as ultra-depressing as you imply directly. Your average failed start-up entrepreneur probably doesn't even get an acqui-hire, but he certainly doesn't wind up "broke, penniless and destitute" either. Solving this kind of problem is in fact the entire point of joint-stock companies as we know them: the founder comes on-board as a majority shareholder, a capital-adding founder, and with a salary paid by the company (once it has any money at all, but why are you founding a company if you have no personal runway?). His personal survival becomes separate from the company's survival, through that wondrous mechanism of investment. But of course, if what we're really talking about is 1-3 cofounders and a small but growing group of investors beginning a joint-stock company in a fashion explicitly designed not to personally endanger anyone, then there's no reason you couldn't run the whole thing as a Mondragon-style cooperative in the first place, with some charter modifications to allow for issuing equity. Now, you could say we need to give the founders an outsized reward for their outsized risk, but after multiple rounds of investment diluting their share ownership, VCs and accelerators and other investors taking spots on the Board of Directors and then further dilution of the founders' individual ownership and control of the firm by the time it reaches any kind of Liquidity Event... Well, it ends up looking less like we're giving outsized rewards to the founders specifically, and more like we're giving outsized rewards to an investor class within a large collective enterprise that could, if the founders were clever and lucky, contain the founders as a large or dominant component. But of course, there's also a dozen ways for the founders to wind up basically proletarians in their own company. So while I do think the cooperative model could do more to honor founding entrepreneurs, I can't say it does distinctly worse than our current model of investor-driven enterprise, ie: capitalism.
- mindcrime 13y agoIt's a fair point that taking investment money, as opposed to debt, changes the equation. Even so, I personally don't mind seeing founders get rewarded for taking the initiative and stress involved in founding a company, as long as all the transactions involved (re: employees, investors, etc.) are all voluntary. then there's no reason you couldn't run the whole thing as a Mondragon-style cooperative in the first place, with some charter modifications to allow for issuing equity. I'm not real familiar with the Mondragon Corporation specifically, but from looking at the Wikipedia article[1] just now, it sounds pretty interesting. I'm a fan of the idea of employee owned collectives and cooperatives (both for profit and non-profit), and see them as just as much a desirable part of our overall society / economy as "traditional" corporations. Maybe more so. Being a libertarian / voluntaryist / anarcho-capitalist / $pick_your_label, I find the modern corporation problematic, in that it explicitly breaks the premise of "liability for the outcome of your actions" for the individual investors. Arguably that's a good thing, because it makes it easier for people to pool their capital and more or less allows for the existence of the modern mega-corporation. Arguably it's a bad thing, because it allows for the existence of the modern mega-corporation. In either case, I'd love to see worker owned collectives, and /or private coops replace both many traditional for-profit companies AND many government agencies / services. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoFor replacing government agencies/services, look into the concept of a "commons trust". The basic idea is that the organization for managing the resource or providing the service holds a property title over the necessary resources, but holds it in-trust on behalf of the general public so that they have strict, legally-enforcible limitations on what they can do with the resource and to whom the benefits must accrue. In general, we can actually make a lot of progress on what I would call "engineering socialism" once we get our brains out of the "individual capitalism versus government socialism" paradigm, a paradigm they only got trapped in by the peculiarities of the Cold War.