3 ms·
Sort of yes. But the dead ends are usually (almost) ignored. Also, what you study is the modern refinement of things people came up with long ago. People don't
by im3w1l 13y ago
Sort of yes. But the dead ends are usually (almost) ignored. Also, what you study is the modern refinement of things people came up with long ago. People don't usually read what Gauss wrote; instead they read a modern text-book.
- leephillips 13y agoExcellent points. In physics we don't trudge through the details of phlogiston theory or Aristotelian mechanics because those are really dead ends. Only specialists in the history of science bother with the real details of those things. But in philosophy it seems that students spend huge amounts of time on anything that ever gained traction. This leads some physicists (maybe Feynman) to conclude that philosophy has no criteria to separate valuable developments from useless stuff; since there are no real standards, they can't distinguish the essential content of their subject matter from its tortuous history.