3 ms·
Cold fusion reactor independently verified, has 10k x the energy density of gas
- danmaz74 13y agoThis situation is the perfect, legitimate situation where patents make sense. I really wonder why Andrea Rossi doesn't simply patent his invention, and let the whole world know how - and if - it really works.
- ywang0414 13y agoThere's an informal italian patent on this. But not an international one, because "offend against the generally accepted laws of physics and established theories".
- danmaz74 13y agoThe real difference is in disclosing the "secret sauce": a patent needs to disclose it, that's the whole point of patents. If that's not so, then it isn't really a patent on this (supposed) invention.
- teamonkey 13y agoThe parent was saying that there are clauses in international patent law that prevent applications for devices such as this, mainly because of time wasting and fraud.
- danmaz74 13y ago@teamonkey: if so, ok. I was also forgetting something I had studied (being Italian): in Italy patents aren't awarded after an examination, they basically just certify the date of your claims. The whole examination and discussion of the patent are left to a trial, if there is ever one regarding it. I guess that' what the OP meant by "informal" patent.
- mtgx 13y agoThis is why I want patents to be limited by how much work was put into creating that "invention". If it only took you a couple of days to come up with it and implement it, then I seriously doubt it's a world changing invention, and something others couldn't have come up with, anywhere in the world. What Andreas is doing will obviously take more than a few days to invent.
- wtvanhest 13y agoWe definitely need to change patent law, but requiring something to take time to be patentable does not seem like a good strategy. 1) Most break through inventions can be broken down in to smaller, patentable parts. Every patentable part at some point was "created" in an instant, rather than days. 2) You could use the logic to argue that software patents make perfectly good sense by saying that you had to spend years experimenting with software, learning what code works and what code doesn't work and understanding the market for various devices before coming up with your groundbreaking software patent on XYZ.
- grecy 13y agoElon Musk covered this. They don't patent things at Space X because their primary competitors are governments, and patent enforceability against governments is questionable at best. I think the same applies here.
- danmaz74 13y agoThis is an interesting point, but the situation here is very different. For space launches there is a very little market, and if eg the Russians undercut you your potential customers will go to them and you're going to lose money. For electricity instead there is so much demand to satisfy that the inventor could make MUCH more money than he ever dreamed of just selling it in the Countries that would respect his patent.
- ywang0414 13y agoIf this gets verified that it produces more energy than it requires to get the thing started, our world will be revolutionized! Can't wait for the update. We can finally get rid of all the oil heads.
- sounds 13y agoI suspect this will need several independent verifications, all of which meet the most stringent standards of scientific rigor. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. Isolate the system in a Caloric chamber, once the device is at operating temperatures, and prove beyond all doubt that there are no hidden energy inputs. Measure heat generated for a period of many hours. The results should be obvious. Document everything for easy repeatability. The Rossi-Focardi "E-Cat" is being seriously questioned. Their credibility is not great. I won't outright call it a scam yet, but I have grave doubts.
- jessriedel 13y agoAndrea Rossi is a guy with a history of being a charlatan. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_(entrepreneur) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_(entrepreneur)
- dragonwriter 13y agoMore info on the page on this particular device: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer Note particularly: Astrophysicist Ethan Siegel commented at scienceblogs saying Rossi did not allow the reactants or products to be measured on this occasion. In the previous tests there were not enough Nickel-62 and Nickel-64 (the only two isotopes which can fuse with hydrogen), at 3.6% and 0.9% respectively, in the reactants to explain the 10% copper output; these isotope levels are typical of natural copper, rather than of fusion by-product. According to Siegel, Rossi also refused to unplug the machine while it was operating despite it being an easy way to surreptitiously power the device. He also added that the supposedly independent testers had to rely on data supplied by Rossi.
- MrQuincle 13y agoYes, terrible! Dumping 70,000 tons of toxic waste! That's a lot!!!
- HarryRotha 13y agoive been following this ever since the hoopla a few years ago. I want it to be real and I want to see the world changed by it, but until I see more verification I'm not getting my hope sup.
- justinjlynn 13y agomeh I'll wait until the paper is peer reviewed before I get excited. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
- joosters 13y agoCold fusion CONFIRMED - for people who live in rooms at temperatures of 859.1 degrees centrigrade, apparently. And who don't need their research papers to be peer-reviewed :)
- raverbashing 13y agoIn other news, room temperature superconductivity was confirmed by researchers at the University of Fairbanks
- stuaxo 13y agoBelieve it when I see it..
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIt will be lovely if this pans out. It will be a challenge as well. But besides the requirement of proof, the curiosity that Rossi continues to seek out funds when, if true, he could be building power plants and under cutting everyone on their cost of power. And thus crushing the power industry and becoming independently wealthy. So that makes me skeptical. And like radio in the past, without understanding how it works, we don't make progress very quickly. Radio turned out to be a real thing, and this could too, but so far I'm still betting on the 'don't pass' line.
- liquidise 13y agoFTA: "If Rossi and Focardi’s cold fusion technology turns out to be real..." The peer review process should really be exercised before looking to publish an article, to avoid just such lines.
- daeken 13y agoHere's a great breakdown of why this paper is junk science: http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2013/05/21/the-e-cat-is-back-and-people-are-still-falling-for-it/ http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2013/05/21/the-e-cat... Simply put, they didn't actually exclude external sources of power, nor did they properly measure before and after fusion. The test also happened only when the device was on. This isn't an independent review; it's equivalent to me looking at it and saying "wow, that box is pretty!"
- yid 13y agoFor everyone commenting on this story -- the link daeken posted is well worth a read. Very reasonable measures were completely ignored. The most amazing to me was the fact that external power was never disconnected from the device!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Why does anyone put up with it? Some because they are hopeless naive, as you say, but probably some because they desperately want what is being claimed to be true, so they accept things they wouldn't generally accept in this specific case.
- Alex3917 13y agoIt doesn't sound like it's even junk science; as far as I can tell there isn't even any natural phenomenon that they're claiming to have tested.
- GravityWell 13y agoThe only incredible thing is that Rossi seems to keep getting attention, which I suspect, along with naive sponsors, is the only thing he really wants.
- JunkDNA 13y ago
- FeatureRush 13y agoOn related note - there is also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion - also works in "lower" temperature, just needs some muons...
- Jabbles 13y ago"which hasn’t yet undergone peer review" "The device subject to testing was powered by 360 W for a total of 96 hours, and produced in all 2034 W thermal." When it does, and the reviewers find that the authors can't even get their units correct, this will be dismissed like every other cold fusion experiment.
- Lexarius 13y agoLet's see him pop it into an electric car and take a cross-continent drive without stopping for a recharge.
- gngeal 13y ago"The cold fusion device being tested has roughly 10,000 times the energy density and 1,000 times the power density of gasoline. Even allowing for a massively conservative margin of error, the scientists say that the cold fusion device they tested is 10 times more powerful than gasoline" Such idiotic claims. What comes next, that meat has twice the energy energy density of a fruit blender? Since when does one compare a fuel and a machine, instead of two fuels?
- ISL 13y agoNeutrons. If it is a cold fusion device (which the arXiv article does not claim), then copious neutron production is almost unavoidable. If I were evaluating something that claimed anything like nuclear power densities, you can be certain that I'd have radiation detectors around, and I'd write about it in my paper. This would be as much for my own safety as for science. A successful invention of an alternative energy source won't require secrecy. That's what a patent is for. It's not something that can be commercialized (or even produced in quantity) without someone tearing it apart and figuring out how it works.
- apsec112 13y agoI'm not a fusion expert, but I studied physics in undergrad, and this seems pretty much impossible. The first obvious question is "how are you overcoming the Coulomb barrier?". Protons absorbing electrons won't just 'happen' - it's energetically unfavorable, requiring 780,000 eV of energy input. (Unbound neutrons are unstable for this reason.) Given that the energy of chemical reactions is usually around 1-3 eV, one has to wonder where the heck all this energy comes from. The second obvious question is "where does the excess energy/momentum go?". If (say) you hit a proton with an electron at 1 MeV, and 0.78 MeV is absorbed in conversion to a neutron, 0.21 MeV of energy and all the electron's momentum still has to go somewhere. Neutrinos weigh almost nothing, so all the momentum has to go into the neutron, which is now traveling at around 500 eV (not 1 eV). You'd likely also get gamma ray emissions. The third obvious question is "what's the reaction cross-section?". Weak force mediated reactions happen very rarely, which is why the neutron's decay time is so long.
- RBerenguel 13y agoI agree with the general sentiment wrt this article, but I can address your first objection: quantum tunneling. Just like in those old (and real, even though energetically deficient) muon-catalysed cold fusion devices
- apsec112 13y agoQuantum tunneling increases the rate of energetically favorable reactions, but it can't create energy from nowhere. Eg. in the muon catalysis case, the reaction (D + T -> He4 + H) produced a huge amount of energy as soon as nuclei could "tunnel through" the barrier. In this case (p + e -> n + v), no energy is produced even after the barrier is overcome; the energy used to overcome the Coulomb barrier goes into the mass of the neutron. Hence, that energy still must come from somewhere.
- RBerenguel 13y agoYes, I realised this a while after answering. A pity muons are so expensive to generate, since at method is theoretically and effectively beautiful. Hope is the last thing you lose, but it's pretty clear this particular case of "cold fusion" is (as the debunking article linked above) shenanigans.
- R_Edward 13y agoWith nickel at $6.64 per pound, and copper at $3.28, I'd be more interested in a device that went the opposite direction. (I mean, since it's not actually performing fusion anyway.)
- metabrew 13y agoExtremely skeptical of course.. but: What if you did crack cold fusion.. imagine the (justifiable) paranoia and measures you would have to take to protect yourself, and your discovery. I'd want to get the plans/schematics in the public domain ASAP. Someone is going to throw money at you to help build bigger and better versions once all doubt is removed anyway.
- uslic001 13y agoWhy does this junk since about LENR keep ending up on the front page of Hacker News? It is the same report over and over again with nothing new added.
- marknutter 13y agoAnnnnd... the article is flagged of the front page.
- ColinWright 13y agoNot just the front page - now gone below to 500s, probably into the 800s and beyond.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- squozzer 13y agoI'm keeping the bubbly on ice for now. Not because the reactor may be a hoax, but even if it's wildly successful -- by which I mean CF replaces all current power generators -- does the estimable readership of HN think it's really going to reduce our energy bill? Think of what goes into your bill -- it's not all a pass-through of whatever the provider had to burn, there's also labor and infrastructure. But let's assume for argument's sake that CF is a plug-in replacement, and it's 1/10th the cost. What makes you think the utility execs will just give that away? They have armies of lobbyists, decades of experience at bamboozling the public, and control of the infrastructure -- in some US states, they even have the power to seize property by force. And when pressed, they'll just restructure their business so that their cost of buying energy is low or nonexistent, in order to justify their rates. Or, more ominously, they'll manipulate the markets for CF materials to maintain or increase their rates. Just a dose of reality. But, hey I could be wrong.
- mark-r 13y agoIf it's cheap enough and doesn't produce toxic byproducts, you could get point-of-use reactors. No more need for utilities. Naturally the utilities would fight that with every fiber of their being. But doesn't everybody here dream of that kind of disruption?