4 ms·
Ask HN: what about email is broken?
I've read many posts on HN, as well as blogs linked here, talking about email being broken. I've yet to see a good list as to what about it is broken, however.
In your thoughts, why is email broken?
- CompelTechnic 13y agoThe inability to send large files is pretty frustrating. The alternative services that can serve as a workaround to this problem (dropbox, etc.) are still relatively clunky as well.
- tehabe 13y agoE-mail was never intended for sending big files, it was for sending text. And for that, I think, e-mail is perfect.
- lemonade 13y agoThese days mail clients like Thunderbird warn you for large attachments, and prompt you to use some other solution. Even better: using the built in XMPP-client they could easily send you infinitely sized files at you@yourdomain.com - if only you would run an XMPP server on your domain
- mike-cardwell 13y agoReliability, privacy, security. When I send an email to somebody, I want to know that it has arrived, and I want to know that the only person that can read it is the recipient. When I receive an email from somebody, I want to know that it definitely came from them. We have SPF, DKIM and OpenPGP (all of which I use). The problem is, mail servers accept mail from domains that don't use SPF and DKIM, and more importantly, other people don't use OpenPGP.
- lemonade 13y agoYou could safely mail me, though. We use the same stack you do, plus DANE for advertising the fingerprint of the certificate to make sure the connection to the mail server is not MitM-ed. And (open)DMARC for giving feedback to mail origins about what (malicious) traffic tried to send from their domain. Well, the technology is there and works as advertised. It is just getting people to adopt, and since people depend on hosting companies hosting companies need to upgrade. That hasn't happened. Ever. But it is not the failure of email, I would say, but a failure of the internet ecosystem that is incapable of upgrading itself because of its fragmentation.
- QuantumGuy 13y agoAs I said earlier in a related post "email clients are stuck in the 90s. The way they look and organized hasn't changed in 20 years. You need to throw out all you think an email client should be and make your own. That is my sincerest suggestion. If you do not believe me go look for yourself. Outlook,Yahoo Mail,Gmail,etc all look the same as the did 20 years ago. I use Thunderbird but I hate how it looks and works." Plus it is still insecure but Mozilla may fix that with Persona.