3 ms·
There are two different questions here: - Why can't we build software as fast as we think? - Why can't we build software as fast as we think we can? The auth
by mckoss 13y ago
There are two different questions here:
- Why can't we build software as fast as we think?
- Why can't we build software as fast as we think we can?
The author probably meant the latter (which is more associated with estimation and prediction).
But I find the former question MUCH more interesting. We've all had the experience of envisioning software solutions that would be useful to us - but then the actual task of developing that software seems much more difficult than the task SHOULD be.
I attribute much of this to IMPEDANCE rather than FRICTION. We are often not using the best tools for the job, and hence suffer great amount of superfluous work in solving any particular problem.
General purpose programming languages may always have this problem; being able to describe any solution means that they are not particularly well suiting to expressing solutions to particular classes of problems).
I've always experienced myself being much more efficient when I have domain-specific languages specifically tailored to the class of problems I want to solve. I think we are moving (slowly) in the direction of developing more targeted languages (e.g. Angular or Dart from Google for client-side web development).
- dools 13y agoActually the title of the article is "Friction: why you can't build software as fast as you think you can" (emphasis here only). Some admin was obviously in an editorial mood and has updated it to confuse everyone.
- jacques_chester 13y agoFred Brooks pointed out in his famous No Silver Bullet essay [1] that the complexity bound on software development is set by the problem domain, not the solution domain. No matter how much better we get at our jobs, the world remains complex and our performance will be bound by that complexity. [1] http://www.cs.nott.ac.uk/~cah/G51ISS/Documents/NoSilverBullet.html http://www.cs.nott.ac.uk/~cah/G51ISS/Documents/NoSilverBulle...