3 ms·
Never, for long periods of time. Modern societies have never really lived without a large state. So almost every new society (or post-revolution) in history ad
by dmix 13y ago
Never, for long periods of time.
Modern societies have never really lived without a large state. So almost every new society (or post-revolution) in history adopted that same practice. But usually with new limitations.
The problem is that once the state is instantiated and given broad power, their power continues to grow and expand out of self-interest and desire for control.
Regardless of capitalism or socialism.
As Rothbard said: "the true utopian is the man who puts all the guns and all the decision-making power into the hands of the central government and then says, 'Limit yourself.'".
- eru 13y agoWhat do you mean by a "large state"? Measured in government expenditure as part of GDP there are big variations between countries. (Incidentally, Singapore has one of the smallest states around.)
- dmix 13y agoMeasuring state power purely based on yearly expenditure is a very limited perspective. At the same time I don't know enough about Singapore's current economic/social situation to comment. I was only stating an observation on the nature of states ability to expand in scope and power regardless of limitations enacted at initiation.
- eru 13y agoYes, it is a very limited perspective. On the other hand, it is one for which data is widely available. > I was only stating an observation on the nature of states ability to expand in scope and power regardless of limitations enacted at initiation. Yes, as e.g. the USA nicely demonstrates.