3 ms·
I agree with you if the stories are taken as "here is what you could have done" or "here is your prognosis". But autism is highly variable. And how it respond
by btilly 13y ago
I agree with you if the stories are taken as "here is what you could have done" or "here is your prognosis". But autism is highly variable. And how it responds to treatment is also variable. Successes are worth looking at because they might be applicable in others.
This particular child does not seem to be able to talk. Completing high level humanities course work really is an accomplishment worth celebrating.
Incidentally, speaking of high functioning autism, I'f long found it ironic that one of the top experts alive today on emotion in animals is herself autistic. See http://templegrandin.com/ http://templegrandin.com/ for more.
(And what, you ask, is the practical value of understanding emotion in animals? Well one thing that she did was improve a slaughterhouse to would not frighten the cows going into it, thereby lessening how much inefficiency they had from frightened animals trying to escape. The ironies mount...)
- thinkcomp 13y agoTemple Grandin's experience, while interesting, is another example of media hype concerning autism that misleads a great number of people into believing that all autistic people can or should aspire to use their disability in furtherance of some greater good. This is not so; if only they should be so lucky. Her experience is not representative of anything.
- VLM 13y ago"Her experience is not representative of anything." I've seen her speak in person at a state fair. She's a pretty good inspirational speaker, would recommend if you ever get a chance. She does better in person than her biographical movie would seem to imply. If she ever gets tired of livestock she probably could 2nd career as a motivational speaker. I'd summarize her state fair speech about her life experiences to something like success comes exclusively from grit, which isn't too far from the original post and/or my own observational experience. For whatever local definition of "greater good" and "success" applies. (edited because I feel the need to rephrase: I saw a speech of hers in person, which (hopefully accurately) summarizes to its a universal fact of ALL humanity that success is the result of grit. Which I'd agree with. However the friction comes from no universal definition of what "greater good" and "success" means across individuals.)